Old Shawnee Pizza - Feedback

Great pizza place appetizers nor worth the price though. read more Great pizza place appetizers nor worth the price though.

Awesome pizza and great customer service! Pizza was done when promised and girl who took my order was super friendly as well as the person I picked up my pizza... read more Awesome pizza and great customer service! Pizza was done when promised and girl who took my order was super friendly as well as the person I picked up my pizza from. We did to go this time but the atmosphere inside looked so fun! Excited to go back and dine in next time! They have a lot of good specials so keep an eye out for those! We did a large pepperoni and a large sausage both were great!

The pizza here is Amazing! This is definitely one of the best pizza places in Kansas. I went with an Alfredo Sauce instead of the red sauce and it was worth it!... read more The pizza here is Amazing! This is definitely one of the best pizza places in Kansas. I went with an Alfredo Sauce instead of the red sauce and it was worth it! Don't forget to try Garlic Knots. Not sure if the lemonade is made in house or not but it's very good. This place deserves 6 stars!

First time there and I loved my visit. The pizza and wings were delicious but the best thing was my waitress and the margarita I had. It was the probably one of... read more First time there and I loved my visit. The pizza and wings were delicious but the best thing was my waitress and the margarita I had. It was the probably one of the best margaritas I have ever had.... I would literally go back just to have another one of their regular margaritas

If you want a Crab Rangoon pizza, that's the place. That's the best special pizza I ever had and I had hundreds. I can't talk to something else on the menu beca... read more If you want a Crab Rangoon pizza, that's the place. That's the best special pizza I ever had and I had hundreds. I can't talk to something else on the menu because that's my pizza. That's a token pizza joint, minus the arcade games. Pizza and beer. What else is necessary in life. recommend and return

Paid for EXTRA mozzarella....no mozzarella at all. Nasty...bye bye. read more Paid for EXTRA mozzarella....no mozzarella at all. Nasty...bye bye.

The food was decent, but the cheese had started to cool by the time it arrived. Italian cuisine is at its best when served piping hot. read more The food was decent, but the cheese had started to cool by the time it arrived. Italian cuisine is at its best when served piping hot.

I ordered through GrubHub, and that part was fine. However, the pizza I received was nothing like the one from the Lenexa location. It might share the same name... read more I ordered through GrubHub, and that part was fine. However, the pizza I received was nothing like the one from the Lenexa location. It might share the same name, but it's nowhere near the quality of the Epic Pizza at OSP Lenexa.

Finding pizza made with genuine ingredients can be a challenge, and the difference really stands out to me. I’ve been enjoying this place for years; it’s my go-... read more Finding pizza made with genuine ingredients can be a challenge, and the difference really stands out to me. I’ve been enjoying this place for years; it’s my go-to for delicious pizza and fantastic toasted sandwiches. As a side note, they sponsored my little league softball team back in the 70s and 80s, and that support still holds significance for me even after 40 years. As for parking, I’ve never had an issue.

Prices are incredibly high for average pizza. It used to be so much better and I was willing to pay for the quality product. It’s now $100 for 2 mediums and the... read more Prices are incredibly high for average pizza. It used to be so much better and I was willing to pay for the quality product. It’s now $100 for 2 mediums and their “biggin” pizza. At that price, it should be a 5 star pizza, hands down. The pizza was floppy and soggy in the middle. Stick to Buffalo State, The Other Place or Johnny’s.

Love the old vibe of this place! And the pizza truly was amazing. I don't like thin crust but I found this pizza crispy yet filling. Delish! That said, service... read more Love the old vibe of this place! And the pizza truly was amazing. I don't like thin crust but I found this pizza crispy yet filling. Delish! That said, service was a struggle. The server appeared to be alone, so this could have simply been a staffing issue on the first trip I've ever had here. Seems that there was someone who showed up halfway through our meal who started helping out. But the service was weird. The single server made a tour of the entire restaurant and took everyone's orders, which made total sense since he was alone. But then he walked right by us twice without stopping. I finally stopped him and asked if we could order and he said he would be right back. Which he was. But it was odd that he walked right by us twice without even acknowledging us while being sure to help everyone else. Aside from that, this place really does seem worth the price. Pizza is costly. The complaints from other patrons in their reviews are valid regarding cost. But this is one of those times when you're getting what you pay for. If you want cheap pizza, then you will certainly be able to get an affordable one at a chain. If you want good, unique pizza then you will pay for it here but you will get what you pay for. There are also really good specials on weeknights. We stopped here before a movie so we lucked out on the $10 medium one topping pizzas. I really wanted to try a specialty, but the cost was prohibitive. Having tried the one topping, I will feel less hesitant about spending the money on a specialty in the future.

Awesome place! Food, atmosphere and personality A Staff cares and it shows Vegetarian options: Italian Paradise and Farmers market both GREAT! Meal type: Dinner... read more Awesome place! Food, atmosphere and personality A Staff cares and it shows Vegetarian options: Italian Paradise and Farmers market both GREAT! Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Pizzas Recommendation for vegetarians: Highly recommend Vegetarian offerings: Large vegetarian selection

Always good food and service Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 read more Always good food and service Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

We ordered chicken Alfredo and a pepperoni pizza, and both dishes were excellent. Our server was attentive, but her voice was quite loud, making it feel like sh... read more We ordered chicken Alfredo and a pepperoni pizza, and both dishes were excellent. Our server was attentive, but her voice was quite loud, making it feel like she was constantly shouting. We enjoyed the vintage pizza pub atmosphere here. Even though this place is quite a distance from our home, we will probably come back. UPDATE: We visited again on October 24 and had the same server. She was fantastic, so I’m increasing my service rating from 4 stars to 5. Food rating: 5 stars.

I had an excellent experience at this restaurant, thanks to the attentive and friendly staff. The atmosphere was outstanding as well, featuring a cozy and invit... read more I had an excellent experience at this restaurant, thanks to the attentive and friendly staff. The atmosphere was outstanding as well, featuring a cozy and inviting vibe that enhanced the dining experience. I wholeheartedly recommend this restaurant for its exceptional service and inviting ambiance.

If you want a Crab Rangoon pizza this is the place. This is the best specialty pizza I've ever had and I've had hundreds. I can't speak to anything else on the... read more If you want a Crab Rangoon pizza this is the place. This is the best specialty pizza I've ever had and I've had hundreds. I can't speak to anything else on the menu because this is my go to pizza. This is a token pizza joint, minus the arcade games.Pizza and beer. What else is required in life. Would recommend and will be back

We each ordered a small pizza, hoping to have some leftovers for the next day. What we got was more like a personal-sized pizza that you would typically find at... read more We each ordered a small pizza, hoping to have some leftovers for the next day. What we got was more like a personal-sized pizza that you would typically find at other restaurants. The gluten-free pizza tasted good, but unfortunately, it wasn't truly safe for those with gluten sensitivities. Both pizzas were around $18 each, plus an extra $3 for the gluten-free crust. Overall, it just wasn't worth it. While the flavor was decent, it didn't match the price. I can't help but wonder how small the personal pizzas must be if this is what they consider a small. If you're planning to order, I suggest steering clear of the small size if you're hungry.

The food is amazing! I'm a regular when it comes to their pizza, but this time I decided to try the Orleans pasta with extra shrimp and crab. Wow, it was packed... read more The food is amazing! I'm a regular when it comes to their pizza, but this time I decided to try the Orleans pasta with extra shrimp and crab. Wow, it was packed with flavor! The portion size was generous too—I ended up taking the leftovers home and was able to feed two more adults with them.

I think I’ve found the ultimate pizza—small but packed with flavor. It’s truly one of the best I’ve ever had, and absolutely delicious! My husband opted for the... read more I think I’ve found the ultimate pizza—small but packed with flavor. It’s truly one of the best I’ve ever had, and absolutely delicious! My husband opted for the luau pizza, which was a great choice. While we felt the prices were a bit on the high side for pizza, we agreed it was worth it. Since we live quite a distance away, this will definitely be a special date night destination for us. The restaurant was lively on a Thursday night at 7:30 PM. For two small pizzas, two drinks, and a slice of carrot cake to take home, we spent around $60. However, I just got home and opened the carrot cake—seriously? It looks like half of it is missing. What a disappointment!

A local Shawnee native wouldn’t trade this place for any other pizza spot in the world! The Crab Rangoon Pizza is truly unique and sets this place apart from th... read more A local Shawnee native wouldn’t trade this place for any other pizza spot in the world! The Crab Rangoon Pizza is truly unique and sets this place apart from the rest!

The manager was quite rude! I placed a simple order for three large pizzas and scheduled a pick-up time an hour in advance. After waiting for 30 minutes, I saw... read more The manager was quite rude! I placed a simple order for three large pizzas and scheduled a pick-up time an hour in advance. After waiting for 30 minutes, I saw several other people receive their pizzas before mine.

It's a shame we live so far away, because this pizza would definitely be a regular favorite for us! Everything we tried was absolutely delicious! My husband can... read more It's a shame we live so far away, because this pizza would definitely be a regular favorite for us! Everything we tried was absolutely delicious! My husband can't stop thinking about the Crimson Rangoon Pizza.