Images
Contribute
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Ellen Treuer likes about Mixed Fillings Pie Shop:
Best pie shop ever!! Are they out of my favorites sometimes yes but that gives me a chance to try new yummy slices. Obviously there’s a lot of people that love the same pie flavor so yeah there’s a chance they won’t have it. Be kind, try a new flavor it may become your new favorite!You guys are 100% the best in town and thank you for being here!! View all feedback.
What Robin Anderson doesn't like about Mixed Fillings Pie Shop:
Get it to go. Maybe I caught them on an off day. Not helpful or friendly. I had the apple after the girl on the counter wouldn’t answer my questions. I would choose something else next time. They had a water pitcher and no cups. Just not a great experience. After standing for a long time, I left half the pie sitting on the counter. No one checked on me at all. No excuse because the other customers cleared out while I... View all feedback.
Get it to go. Maybe I caught them on an off day. Not helpful or friendly. I had the apple after the girl on the counter wouldn’t answer my questions. I would choose something else next time. They had a water pitcher and no cups. Just not a great experience. After standing for a long time, I left half the pie sitting on the counter. No one checked on me at all. No excuse because the other customers cleared out while I stood there. Ugh. Really unfortunate because it looks like a cute homemade shop.
The best key lime pie I have ever had! The chocolate brownie pie (not the correct name) was amazing as well. Run to get your pies here! So delicious!
The coconut cream pie is the best I've ever had! We bought a pie flight (4 slices) for $25. The others were peach/blackberry crumble, strawberry lemon, and French silk. All were delicious and worth the price.
This pie is amazing! We drove over 2 hours and would gladly make the trip again. The slices on the pie flights are very generous and everything we tried was excellent. We especially liked the key lime and lemon lavender. Looking forward to the next trip.
Ok people don't walk but run to this adorable and tasty shop. Friendly vibe and a super clean shop. The pies are awesome and the prices are great. Eat it there or take it home you will not be disappointed. I drove 45 minutes one way and plan on doing it again soon
Full Menu
Restaurant Category
Main Course
More information
QR-code link to the menu
