Pic-A-Lilli Inn - Shamong
Pic-A-Lilli Inn
Menu
The menu of Pic-A-Lilli Inn from Shamong includes 237 dishes. On average the dishes or drinks on the menu cost approximately $9.0. You can view the categories on the menu below.
Pic-A-Lilli Inn in Shamong, NJ, is a charming American restaurant that boasts an impressive average rating of 4.4 stars. Open daily from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM, it’s the perfect spot to enjoy a delicious meal. To ensure you have a table waiting for you, be sure to call ahead at (609) 268-2066 for reservations. In addition to its delectable menu, Pic-A-Lilli Inn features live music, creating a delightful atmosphere for your dining experience. If you're looking for similar venues, consider checking out Wawa or Valenzano Family Winery. We would love to hear about your visit—feel free to share your experience and leave a review!.
Images
Reservation request for Pic-A-Lilli Inn
Feedback
Pic-A-Lilli has become a local staple, renowned for its wings and vibrant atmosphere. While many diners rave about the flavorful sauces and friendly service, opinions on the wings are mixed. Some patrons find them disappointingly small and overcooked, feeling that the hype may overshadow the reality. Others praise the quality and taste, particularly highlighting unique combinations in the sauces. The cozy setting and attentive staff consistently receive accolades. Despite some inconsistencies in food quality, it remains a cherished spot for families and friends, making it worth a visit for those seeking a lively dining experience.
The food was delicious, the service was friendly, and the portion sizes were just right. I’m not usually a fan of wings, so I decided to try the chicken fingers and absolutely loved them; they were all white meat with no fatty or gristly bits. My husband was tempted to try their famous wings but wasn't sure if his stomach could handle them, so he chose a burger instead—and he enjoyed that just as much. Both meals came with fries, which were also excellent.
The food is bangin and service is great. The ambiance is filled with the relaxing sounds of motorcycles, loud conversations and breaking dishes in the kitchen. Kid friendly because they are noisy too.
Cozy place with lots of selections on tap as well as drink specials and excellent bar food. Wings are a must when you go. Prices are fair and food comes out hot and fresh. Place is very popular so be prepared for a crowd. Outdoor seating isavailable. Bar and table seating available inside.
I wanted to love this place since it had SO many great reviews but unfortunately our visit was horrible. The server was not very friendly. We ordered wings, ears, curly fries, cole slaw and some corn nugget app. The wings were so small! What a HUGE letdown.The coleslaw cost $4 for this tiny container! What a rip off. Their curly fries were the best thing and they were obviously froma frozen bag. I asked our server for hot sauce on the side because the sauce wasn't spicy at all, she never brought it out. Istill left a good tip $18 on a $93 bill but we will never return here. Not sure if so many people love it because it's a localspot but spending over $100 for that quality is ridiculous.
Menu
Finger Food
Fried Jalapeno Green Beans$5.8Family Owned
Grilled Russian Turkey$11.8King Of The Wings!
Ear Basket$10.8
Tail Basket$10.8
Pic's Buffalo Sampler$24.5The Original Pic-A-Lilli Inn
Pic Burger$14.7
More information
QR-Code for the menu

This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 4.7 / 5 (708 reviews)Steak Italian Bar-lounge Wine PastaLa Campagnola
439 OakShade RdNJ 08088, Shamong, United States
"This is one of the top Italian restaurants in South Jersey!"
★ 4.7 / 5 (3769 reviews)Wine Steak Burgers Sandwiches PubValenzano Winery
US Route 206 1090, 08088 Shamong, US
"Great service and staff. Best winery in NJ"
★ 4.6 / 5 (5520 reviews)Italian Delivery Services SeafoodLa Campagnola
Oakshade Road 439, 08088 Shamong, US
"Food was excellent you can't go wrong"