Nick And Gina - Selden

Unmatched in quality! Owner Steve and his team are an incredible group of people. I called Steve on Wednesday for a catering order for 25 people that I needed by Friday (today) for our Associate's Day at work. Without hesitation, Steve accepted the order. The level of attention to detail here is remarkable. Every dish was outstanding, and all 300 employees can’t stop raving about how much they enjoyed the meal. They delivered in three waves, and each time, the gentlemen were prompt, respectful, and friendly. I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a lovely, quiet evening with a partner or family. They have a wonderful family-friendly atmosphere, and you’ll be pleasantly surprised by the menu! Steve and his crew create authentic, delicious dishes. Thank you for making today such a success! I truly appreciate all the hard work and effort that went into it!

The food at this restaurant is consistently excellent and has a modern flair. However, my recent experience on a Friday was disappointing due to the service. One of the new staff members seemed very inexperienced—she was quite rude, not sociable, frequently raised her voice, and often forgot what I ordered. When I arrived, she was unhelpful, and I noticed her struggling with the ordering system on the computer. I’m not sure if she has experience as a front-of-house staff member. On a positive note, Steve and his family are wonderful, and their food is always top-notch.

This restaurant is the best-kept secret in Suffolk! The food is outstanding, and the staff is wonderful. I've catered events here for company celebrations and brought many guests over the years, all of whom have become loyal fans of Nick and Gina. It’s truly a fantastic place. But let's keep this under wraps—I don’t want too many people knowing about it; I’d rather not have to make a reservation! :-p

Pizza is SUPER Jummy!! Online prices are not updated, however, which is a bit deceived. Was not happy to find out what I thought I was paying wasn't the same when I got there. Owner said he works to update them, but still the same unfortunately. Pizza is worth whatever it costs! Enough to go back!

It's hard to find a great pizza place and we did when we found Nick and Gina's. The food is great, from hero's to dinners to pizza. It's nice to find a pizza place that's not a hit or miss. They are always friendly. It's great when you walk in there and the pizza man is singing the Italian songs. Thank you to the owners and staff. Keep up the great work.