Trophy Pizza - Menu

The service here is consistently solid. While it does get quite busy on game days and they might not be able to give you their full attention, generally speakin... read more The service here is consistently solid. While it does get quite busy on game days and they might not be able to give you their full attention, generally speaking, I've found the service to be excellent. Over the past year, they have expanded their seating area, allowing you to order and enjoy your food—or drinks, if you prefer—on-site. They also have a lovely outdoor seating option. As for the pizza, it's quite good—an East Coast style. The slices aren't huge, but the price is reasonable at $3.50 for a cheese slice. Similar to many places in New York, the pizza is pre-made but they heat it up for you before serving. One thing to keep in mind is that if you want to order a whole pizza, it's a good idea to call ahead, as it may take some time for them to prepare it. They only accept credit cards—no cash.

I tried calling two different phone numbers for this restaurant, but neither one answered. I also checked their website, and it seems that their FourSquare list... read more I tried calling two different phone numbers for this restaurant, but neither one answered. I also checked their website, and it seems that their FourSquare listing is expired. It appears that this place may be permanently closed. If that's not the case, it certainly seems like they don't care about their customers.