Five Points Cafe - Sayville

#7 - Seafood - Sayville, Breakfast-brunch, Salad
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Reservation
Reservation request for Five Points Cafe.

Five Points Cafe

Five Points Cafe
4.1 / 5 (3083 reviews)

Description

5 Points Cafe in Sayville offers a mixed dining experience. While some dishes like the burgers and Parmesan crusted chicken sandwich are recommended, others like the lobster roll are best avoided. The atmosphere is lively with live music and a cozy vibe, but can get loud during peak hours. Service is mostly efficient, with standout server Alyssa mentioned. The menu offers a good variety of American-style dishes and cold drinks. Overall, 5 Points Cafe is a solid spot for quality food in Sayville, just be cautious about certain menu items and the potential for noisy evenings with live music.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Lizette

Reservation request for Five Points Cafe

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4.1 / 5 from 3083 reviews
kimberly-w-store5
28.11.2023

This restaurant is fantastic! We thoroughly enjoyed the special arugula salad, a definite fall favorite! The zucchini sticks were also a standout, almost like a meal on their own. The service was excellent as well.

juju-w
28.11.2023

I had a fantastic California burger here with live music on a Sunday night. The burger was cooked perfectly and the service was excellent. I have no complaints. The outdoor seating area was also very nice.

mariah-b-fern03
28.11.2023

The restaurant was mediocre. The chicken fingers and fries had a food-truck style. They offer a variety of appetizers, but surprisingly did not have fried calamari. My husband...

lizette-gonzalez-chu
11.09.2024

Great place for food and drinks. Tried many different items on the menu and all were great. Staff is super friendly and attentive.

june-v-chef464
11.09.2024

Finally tried 5 points cafe..live in East islip and frequent alot of restaurants in sayville..so DISAPPOINTED..we sat at bar on Sunday for football.. PAIGE was bartender.. OMG..she spent her time on her phone and left bar unattended for 25 minutes as Waitress Carly had to fill in. If the owner reads this please look at cameras..you need to get rid of her..bar was empty..hello

Menu

  • Hamburgers

    Buffalo Style Beef Burger
    Buffalo Style Beef Burger

    red hot sauce blue cheese

    $11.9
  • Soups

    Fresh Homemade Soups Daily
    Fresh Homemade Soups Daily

    ask your server for today's selection

    $4.9
  • Dessert

    Cookies And Cream Milkshakes
    Cookies And Cream Milkshakes
    $4.9
  • Food

    Idaho French Fries
    Idaho French Fries
    $4.2
  • Shakes

    Vanilla Milkshakes
    Vanilla Milkshakes
    $4.9
  • Lunch And Dinner Drinks

    Strawberry Milkshakes
    Strawberry Milkshakes
    $4.9

FAQ

Smoking is prohibited in the building.

The joint offers the opportunity to view sports events on a TV / screen.

The diner is accessible and can therefore also be used with a wheelchair or physiological limitations.

You can also pay for your menus with various credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.