Five Points Cafe - Sayville
Five Points Cafe
Menu
The menu of Five Points Cafe from Sayville comprises about 71 different menus and drinks. On average you pay about $7.2 for a dish / drink.
5 Points Cafe in Sayville offers a mixed dining experience. While some dishes like the burgers and Parmesan crusted chicken sandwich are recommended, others like the lobster roll are best avoided. The atmosphere is lively with live music and a cozy vibe, but can get loud during peak hours. Service is mostly efficient, with standout server Alyssa mentioned. The menu offers a good variety of American-style dishes and cold drinks. Overall, 5 Points Cafe is a solid spot for quality food in Sayville, just be cautious about certain menu items and the potential for noisy evenings with live music.
Images
Reservation request for Five Points Cafe
Feedback
Was Kimberly W at Five Points Cafe a mag?
This restaurant is fantastic! We thoroughly enjoyed the special arugula salad, a definite fall favorite! The zucchini sticks were also a standout, almost like a meal on their own. The service was excellent as well. View all feedback.
What Mariah B dislikes about Five Points Cafe:
The restaurant was mediocre. The chicken fingers and fries had a food-truck style. They offer a variety of appetizers, but surprisingly did not have fried calamari. My husband... View all feedback.
Very cool vibe in this small town. Burgers are absolutely delicious, drinks are cold, prices are reasonable, and the live music by Vinny and Lexi make it even better. P.S... the staff is very friendly as well. What's not to like about 5 points? We'll done
First time here for my friend and myself and we couldn’t have been happier. Such a comfortable, inviting atmosphere. So many yummy choices on the menu! My reuben was so delicious and the sweet potato fries were AMAZING! My friend thoroughly enjoyed her crispy chicken wrap. Our waitress was really friendly, and very attentive which we truly appreciated. This may have been our first time here, but it certainly won’t be our last!
Great spot in Sayville to enjoy some quality food, and drinks. It's an American style cafe with both inside, and outside seating, and also has live music on the outside patio. The food was very good... I ordered the parmesan crusted chicken sandwich with waffle fries, and a mango margarita.... both highly recommended. I came up from Florida to visit family, and we decided to go here for dinner, and simple quality time together. Our server, Alyssa, did a wonderful job, and should be recognized for her outstanding effort, and attention to detail. I give her a 6 out of 5 . I highly recommend giving this place a chance if you get the opportunity
Great place for food and drinks. Tried many different items on the menu and all were great. Staff is super friendly and attentive.
Finally tried 5 points cafe..live in East islip and frequent alot of restaurants in sayville..so DISAPPOINTED..we sat at bar on Sunday for football.. PAIGE was bartender.. OMG..she spent her time on her phone and left bar unattended for 25 minutes as Waitress Carly had to fill in. If the owner reads this please look at cameras..you need to get rid of her..bar was empty..hello
Full Menu
Hamburgers
Buffalo Style Beef Burger$11.9Soups
Fresh Homemade Soups Daily$4.9Dessert
Cookies And Cream Milkshakes$4.9Food
Idaho French Fries$4.2Shakes
Vanilla Milkshakes$4.9Lunch And Dinner Drinks
Strawberry Milkshakes$4.9
More information
QR-Code for the menu
This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 4.3 / 5 (5718 reviews)Pizza Italian Breakfast Fish PastaLa Tavola
West Main Street 183, 11782 Sayville, US
"Excellent food and service as always. Cannot wait to go back"
★ 4.3 / 5 (6726 reviews)Pizza Italian DessertsButera's
Middle Rd 100, 11782-3100 Sayville, US
"Great food and great Service. A go to place in our book!"
★ 4.2 / 5 (5694 reviews)#22 Seafood in Sayville Sushi AsianKoi Sushi
West Main Street 136, 11782 Sayville, US
"There sushi is awesome! Highly recommend. Food: 5 Service: 5"