Eggstraordinary Cafe - Sarasota

I recently made a quick stop at this restaurant. The prices are comparable to other brunch or breakfast spots. The staff was quite busy but still friendly. The food was decent. During my last visit, I had the omelette which was filled with a variety of toppings. This was a unique experience as usually everything is cooked together, rather than just being placed inside a ready omelette. The potatoes were also quite good.

This restaurant serves the best breakfast in Florida, and breakfast is my favorite! The service is outstanding and the prices are very affordable. The servers never pressure you to pay as soon as your food is served. It has become our favorite spot for weekly breakfast. I would rate it a 10/10.

My family of 26 African Americans traveled to Sarasota for a beach weekend and wanted to have brunch at Eggs-traordinary Cafe. Unfortunately, the owner turned us away, stating that she could only seat 8 of us at a time because having all 26 of us would not be good for her business. We then went to First Watch instead, where we had a delicious meal and received excellent hospitality.

Good simple food! It's often a little too popular but worth a bit of a wait. Nice staff who are amazing at remembering you! Never had a negative experience there.

My husband ordered a 1-1-1 with eggs over medium. Our breakfast arrived promptly. He started buttering it when he realized the pancake was raw inside. He let the waitress know and she took the plate back. She brought his plate back with the same pancake on it. Cooked more but mushy from the butter and the egg was cold. My husband asked to speak to the manager. She came over and he began telling her about the pancake. To our utter disbelief she began to talk about how the storm (Ian) was to blame. I realize the storm affected everyone in different ways. We have found ourselves homeless. But to blame the storm for not doing what was right?