Caragiulo's Italian American Food - Feedback

Food was excellent. Everything is fresh! Plenty of outdoor seating and service was very good. Our waitress Elisabeth who was originally from NY like us was grea...

We met a friend here. It's a stalwart in SRQ. We always sit in the bar area. The food is consistent, tasty and very cheap. Many regular customers. The place is...

Very recommended as an absolute must-see, this was my first time to come here, then to realize that this is an original Italian restaurant that has been in the...

Best Italian restaurant by far in Sarasota. Would give this restaurant 6 stars if possible. Great service, fantastic food, and for a great value. Had two entire...

Delicious comfort Italian. Chicken is organic, kids meal has make your own pizza. Had ribeye special will edible flowers on top for color. Will return.

We very much enjoyed the food and atmosphere at Caragiulo's. I ordered the ‘eggplant parmesan al forno’, which is layers of eggplant, tomato, ricotta mozzarella...

Dinner was amazing. Our server who’s worked there for many years really catered to our 3 year old. It was a great experience!

Always a pleasure to dine with you at the holidays. Love the Christmas ambience and cozy interior. Rashid/Marco is an excellent, personable, knowledgable waiter...

Lots of confusion about meals. None of our meals came out together. Wrong orders come out. Waiter tried hard to accommodate. Mess up was with kitchen. Drinks th...

Wow. The wine options are divine (I ordered the montepulciano), the wedding soup had decadent meatballs, and I ordered the special which was a porcini tortellin...

We stumbled upon this gem just 350 yards from our hotel, the Aloft. It's a delightful casual Italian restaurant offering fantastic drinks, delicious entrees, an...

We had a wonderful experience at Caragiulos. I made a reservation for seven people over the phone a few weeks in advance, and it was very easy. The atmosphere i...

I absolutely love this restaurant! We just finished our meal at this fantastic dining spot! The food was delicious, the waiter was amazing, and it truly feels l...