Reviews
What Everette Will likes about Cafe Amalfi:
Truly a place that cares about what they cook for you. In town for a friend's wedding and walked over here from our hotel and was not disappointed at all! I will be finding time before we head home to go back. The pizza is superb and the mozzarella sticks .... I've never put a better piece of fried mozzarella in my mouth before. I wish I could pack them up and take them home with me. View all feedback. What Cassie McKenzie doesn't like about Cafe Amalfi:
We decided to try out this restaurant. The food and service were okay, but the ambiance and presentation lacked sophistication. Our meals were served on paperboard with plastic utensils. The menu was extensive, but the items we tried were only average. We also got two pizzas to go, so we cannot speak to their quality. I suggested to the owner, John, that he consider using proper utensils and plates, but he did not se... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
The food, service, and atmosphere were all deserving of 5 stars! We had originally planned to eat elsewhere, but ended up stopping at this restaurant to pick up...
read moreWe decided to try out this restaurant. The food and service were okay, but the ambiance and presentation lacked sophistication. Our meals were served on paperbo...
read moreFantastic pizza located right across from Siesta Key beach. The pizza is authentic, handmade, and you can always spot the owner with flour on his apron!
The cafe amalfi was close and had a nyc friendly charm. the owner was in the did of nyc as we were, so we were back assured. the first red flag was however the...
read moreOmg... what a delight! I was sitting outside eating ice cream at one of his tables cause all were full at the ice cream place... he came out and asked if he cou...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThis was one of worst food orders we have ever had. We ordered Chicken Marsala, Stuffed Shells, Tomato Caprese Salad and Tiramisu. The side salad was literally...
read moreFirst time ordering from here. Pizza was burnt on the bottom and was limp and all the toppings fell off. Eggplant rollatini was ok but not impressive. Wont be o...
read moreThe chicken parmesan was amazing! The angel hair pasta and sauce were also excellent! I will definitely be ordering from this restaurant again.
The bow tie pasta was disappointing as it came in a red sauce instead of white and was missing peas. The calzone had too much bread and not enough ham.
The food at this restaurant was absolutely amazing, and the prices were very affordable!
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more