Stachey's - Salem

#15 - Order Vegetarian Salem, Salad, Pizza

Stachey's

Stachey's
3.9 / 5 (1074 reviews)

Description

Stachey’s in Salem, NH, stands out for its gigantic subs and exceptional pizza, including a beloved buffalo chicken variant with a unique sweet sauce. Patrons rave about its generous portion sizes and great deals. However, multiple experiences reveal inconsistent customer service, particularly over the phone, with staff occasionally being dismissive or rude. Cleanliness has also been called into question, impacting the overall dining experience. While the food quality is generally praised, a mix of service challenges detracts from the restaurant's overall appeal. Nevertheless, many loyal customers continue to return for the flavorful offerings.

Last update: 08.07.2026 from: Anonym

Feedback

★ 3.9 / 5 from 1074 reviews

I ordered a large cheese pizza to go I was told about 10 mins and I waited about 20 mins in reality and the pizza was not hot at all I ate warm pizza and I am a regular that would always count on a fresh hot cheese pizza very disappointed today.

I usually LOVE the chicken cutlet parm sub and whenever Im in Salem I stop by for one. Yesterday picked one uparound 12:45pm and I was very dissappointed. I specifically said sauce and cheese and there was very little sauce, and I didn 't see or taste ANY cheese! In addition, though the chicken was plentiful, it was overly fried ....just so disappointed because I always counted on this establishment. I rarely order from my own area anymore because of small portions and not so great quality. Looks like Ill be making my own from now on.

Stopped in and got their Florentine thin crust and it was excellent. Super crispy, cooked perfectly, and everything tasted fresh and balanced the guy with the hat at the pizza counter making the pizza was great really friendly and welcoming. Made the whole experience better. Definitely coming back. It seems that they get busy so there might be a little wait time.

predovic-kianna-1
10.04.2025

Whether you're getting a big ol' sub or a nice stack of pizzas, Stachey's has you covered. Their sweet sauce, gourmet style pizza slaps so hard you'll never want to go elsewhere again. You can't beat their buy two large get a free small pizza deal.Other places have deals but they don't have this absolutely perfect recipe. Does it make good leftovers, you may ask? Coldpizza, reheated pizza, room temp pizza left out for a few hours. Stachey's pizza is the absolute best pizza New England has tooffer. Their subs are fresher than Subway and tastier than Jimmy John's. Don't settle for fast food, that stuff is overpricedand usually terrible. Place your order here for a guaranteed quality meal.

tamia-bradtke
10.04.2025

Everytime I come here from CT I get a pizza. I really wish this pizza was in CT. It's one of the best tasting pizzas ever. Come bring a stacheys over here we need a good pizza place! ????

FAQ

The restaurant offers the opportunity to watch sports events on a TV / screen.

The rooms in the restaurant are wheelchair accessible and can also be used with a wheelchair or physiological disabilities.

The restaurant also takes credit cards from the common providers as a means of payment.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.