Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What User likes about Pauly's Cafe:
Tasty food, friendly staff, reasonable prices. We ate here twice on our visit in St. Mary's enjoyed it both times. Offer many different options including several vegetarian choices. View all feedback.
What Charles Freeman doesn't like about Pauly's Cafe:
I used to visit Pauly's at St Mary's but found it open today after it being closed during my last two attempts. I sat at the tiki bar as usual, but it looked messy and neglected since hurricane Matthew struck in 2016. After having three beers, I left feeling very disappointed. View all feedback.
Amazing, I had the Twin Tournedos and there is no word to describe how delicious it was. My friend had the Primavera and ate every last bite. Small place with great taste.
Large small space from the beaten path only make sure you have correct change
Watch Kelly on the Tiki hat!!! She's the hostesses with the most! Always in knowledge with the locals and holds a great mix of convo for tourists. Times are always easy and funny when it's at the wheel. What a jewel!
Good food, good people everyone is always welcome like family
Tasty food, friendly staff, reasonable prices. We ate here twice on our visit in St. Mary's enjoyed it both times. Offer many different options including several vegetarian choices.
Full Menu
Download MenuRestaurant Category
Sandwiches
Pasta
More information
QR-code link to the menu
