Casey's - Rushville

#13 - Fast Food - Rushville, #16 - Pizza - Rushville, American

Casey's

Casey's
3.7 / 5 (9 reviews)

Description

Despite a loyal following praising the friendly staff and generous, flavorful burritos featuring Casey’s brand products, this restaurant struggles with customer service and operational consistency. Reports include rude treatment when cashing lottery tickets, confusing payment issues with double charges, malfunctioning air machines, and unreliable opening hours. While the food earns positive remarks, management’s dismissive responses to concerns and inconsistencies in service leave many patrons frustrated, casting a shadow over an otherwise promising dining experience.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Dave

Feedback

★ 3.7 / 5 from 9 reviews
dave-harlan-1
01.05.2024

I stopped for air, the machine took my money and provided no air. The manager said it wasn?t her machine, though it does say ?Casey?s? right on the front, and I?d have to call the number on the machine.

shanna-walston
01.05.2024

Literally sitting here waiting on the store to open at 5 so I can grab some breakfast pizza and their still not open, I'm starting to think whoever was supposed to open the store is not coming to do so. All I wanted was some pizza smh ????

jake-kristen
01.05.2024

I visited the Rushville, IN-3 location to cash a lottery ticket, and I was harshly scolded by a staff member for wanting to do so. She insisted that the line was too long, despite the fact that there was no one behind me. I will not be returning to this location.

carla-hall-student98
01.05.2024

I simply adore Casey's! They have an extensive selection of products and services. Their pizza is amazing!

daniel-smith-beach79
01.05.2024

I frequently stop by this place for work, and the staff is amazing. The burritos are always loaded with delicious fillings, and they also have excellent Casey's brand products available.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.