New Milford Cafe - Rootstown

American, Cafe, Coffee

New Milford Cafe

★ 4.0 / 5 (738 reviews)

The neighborhood bar offers a charming atmosphere, friendly staff, and appealing food, especially their Friday Fish dinners and Jumbo Wings. However, service has been inconsistent, with reports of long waits and inattentive staff. While some diners rave about the tasty offerings and attentive service, others have faced frustrations like poorly cooked meals and unclean tables. The ambiance has potential, but the establishment needs to improve service qualities and food consistency. For those seeking a casual spot for drinks, it might suffice, but diners hoping for a satisfying meal may want to reconsider their choice.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Sheryl

Images

Contribute

Feedback

★ 4 / 5 from 738 reviews

Was User at New Milford Cafe a mag?
The service was excellent, even though we were the only guests on the terrace (which was unusually beautiful that day). The food was amazing, and I can't wait to sample more dishes from the menu! It genuinely felt like I was back home in New York, with great music, attentive staff, and fantastic food! View all feedback.

What Mikayla Mikes dislikes about New Milford Cafe:
Waited over 45 minutes in an empty restaurant for a 6 wings, couple hamburgers, and hot dogs. Server has an attitude. French fries were rock solid. Jojo fries were undercooked. Wings were decent, but they didn’t toss them. Skimpy with the coney sauce. Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1 View all feedback.

Mic

18.11.2023

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Food is extremely reasonable!!! Can’t beat it!!! Drinks are always very good!!

gordon

18.11.2023

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Food average, Very loud ,very old building Price per person: $1–10 Food: 2 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 2

Christopher

18.11.2023

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

If you are a Cheers fan, it's like everyone knows your name. Great atmosphere, friendly fun service. Those beer battered fries are out of this world great. Went there one night for one dollar burgers and dogs. They were exceptional. Oh, great tunes and ice cold beers too. Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: 1 00 Burger Day Wednesday

Sheryl

18.03.2025

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Price per person: $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Jumbo Wings

Mark

18.03.2025

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

I stop here whenever I am in town. Try the wings. Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Feedback