Joe's Brooklyn Pizza Henrietta

Thank you! This is the best pizza I have ever tasted. I recommend getting the thin crust XL for extra-large slices!

I visited the restaurant around 1 pm on a Thursday to grab a slice of pizza. Despite having a good variety, the slices looked like they had been sitting out since 10:30 am. I noticed they had just put out a fresh pepperoni and cheese slice, but the pepperoni was burnt. I decided to order a slice with sausage, meatball, and ricotta, even though it appeared old. When the cook was about to put it in the oven, I asked how much it would cost and was surprised to hear it would be over $7 for just one slice. I politely declined and the cook agreed that the price was too high. Although I didn't taste the pizza, based on appearance alone, the price seemed unreasonable for a regular large slice.