Mikey's Pizza Pit Stop - Feedback

This was my first time at this restaurant and it was absolutely amazing! I loved it so much, especially the wet burritos which were awesome. Even my husband enj... read more This was my first time at this restaurant and it was absolutely amazing! I loved it so much, especially the wet burritos which were awesome. Even my husband enjoyed it. We will definitely be coming back here more often. In my opinion, the owner should be very proud of their recipe. The service was great and the atmosphere was also top-notch. We had a takeout dinner and the price per person was between $50-100. Overall, I would give the food, service, and atmosphere all a rating of 5.

It was okay, but won't eat there again. Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $30–50 Food: 2 Service: 2 Atmosphere: 2 read more It was okay, but won't eat there again. Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $30–50 Food: 2 Service: 2 Atmosphere: 2

First time there, we got carry out. The place was pleasant. I ordered a pizza with everything, breadsticks, cauliflower and mushrooms. First off the breadsticks... read more First time there, we got carry out. The place was pleasant. I ordered a pizza with everything, breadsticks, cauliflower and mushrooms. First off the breadsticks were great I loved them! Cauliflower was also good! My husband liked the mushrooms too! Now we get to the more disappointing part- surprisingly the pizza. The very FIRST bite I took, I got a bone sliver in my tooth from the sausage! I thought ok, not a good first experience but it happens sometimes with sausage. The sauce wasn’t my favorite either. But if I gave my rating yesterday it probably would be more on the 3-4 range. However, today I got out the leftover pizza and split a piece of pizza with my son. So a half of a slice. Again in my VERY first bite- I got ANOTHER bone sliver! I thought no way this is possible but sure enough I spit out my bite and there it was, fairly big. This can take your pizza experience to poor pretty quick. My husband has had their pizza before and said it was pretty good from what he remembered but he only got pepperoni. So while the appetizers were really good I’m not sure I’d give them another try.

Great place to eat. Good food. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 4 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4 read more Great place to eat. Good food. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 4 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4

Nothing spectacular... It's definitely over priced . 10 dollars for 10 fried pickles. But we got the sampler platter for 16.99 that comes with 4 mottarella stic... read more Nothing spectacular... It's definitely over priced . 10 dollars for 10 fried pickles. But we got the sampler platter for 16.99 that comes with 4 mottarella sticks, 10 potato wedges 6 boneless wings, 6 onion rings an 2 soft drinks for 6 dolars.. so it's about $20 dollars a person to eat here

We have the nashville hot wings and a chicken bacon ranch sandwich,both were amazing! and the service was good. I loved this place but I don't know if I give ba... read more We have the nashville hot wings and a chicken bacon ranch sandwich,both were amazing! and the service was good. I loved this place but I don't know if I give back bc, it's very expensive $15 for ten very small wings and $14 for a sandwich .

Love their fresh made pizzas and wings, sad they can not be open in evenings. TY for quick delicious service! Pls Order early and often. When Covid/low staffing... read more Love their fresh made pizzas and wings, sad they can not be open in evenings. TY for quick delicious service! Pls Order early and often. When Covid/low staffing is over, what favorite restaurants do you want to see remain open?! Support your local businesses now.

I was in town for a couple days and decided to check Mikey's Pizza Pit Stop out. Had pizza and wings the first night and the second night had the Italian club s... read more I was in town for a couple days and decided to check Mikey's Pizza Pit Stop out. Had pizza and wings the first night and the second night had the Italian club sandwich. Both were excellent and very tasty. Servers were very friendly and attentive and the food arrived in a reasonable amount of time. I would certainly recommend this eating establishment to others!

Mikey's was great as usual . The staff is always friendly too .all 3 of us enjoyed our meals read more Mikey's was great as usual . The staff is always friendly too .all 3 of us enjoyed our meals

Just ordered 2 Sheff's Salads. I was amazed at my total take out Bill of $30.00 after my $4.oo tip to the order taker. I'm still a bit stumped. read more Just ordered 2 Sheff's Salads. I was amazed at my total take out Bill of $30.00 after my $4.oo tip to the order taker. I'm still a bit stumped.

The best part of the meal was the breadsticks, but the sandwich was overpriced and lacking in ingredients. One sandwich had a thin slice of ham with no cheese,... read more The best part of the meal was the breadsticks, but the sandwich was overpriced and lacking in ingredients. One sandwich had a thin slice of ham with no cheese, and the other sandwiches were mostly just bread. The $14 tiny pitcher of beer was also deemed too expensive, especially when there are larger options available across the street for $10. Despite having enjoyed the restaurant in the past, the reviewer has decided not to return due to the decline in quality. The reviewer acknowledges that they have visited many times and have noticed a change in the restaurant. They are willing to pay higher prices for quality food, but feel that they could have a similar experience for much less at a different establishment.

My family and I visited this restaurant on a Monday evening. Our waitress was very friendly with a playful and snarky attitude that we loved. The service was gr... read more My family and I visited this restaurant on a Monday evening. Our waitress was very friendly with a playful and snarky attitude that we loved. The service was great and the pizza was delicious. The breadsticks were also a hit with us. There was plenty of parking available, with more than 20 spots, and we were able to park right by the entrance.

Mikey's Pizza Pitstop is a fantastic option for pizza and wings in the Rochester, Indiana area. The Buffalo pizza, in particular, is delicious with a generous a... read more Mikey's Pizza Pitstop is a fantastic option for pizza and wings in the Rochester, Indiana area. The Buffalo pizza, in particular, is delicious with a generous amount of chicken and cheese. However, it can be a bit salty, so keep that in mind. The BBQ sauce on the wings may be lacking, but the wings themselves are cooked perfectly. While Mikey's prices are a bit higher than other local pizza joints, the quality of the food definitely makes it worth it. The atmosphere at Mikey's is laid-back and welcoming, with good music and attentive staff. Our server was friendly and made sure we had everything we needed. Overall, I recommend Mikey's Pizza Pitstop to anyone in search of a tasty pizza and wings experience, but be prepared for the higher prices and the salty Buffalo pizza.

Food was great, and the picture is of the small pork tenderloin, and most of the fried mushrooms were already gone by the time I took the picture. Delicious ?? read more Food was great, and the picture is of the small pork tenderloin, and most of the fried mushrooms were already gone by the time I took the picture. Delicious ??

First time here and OMG AMAZING loved it so much ??? wet burritos awesome ??? evwn my husband loved it we well definitely be eating here more often in my opinio... read more First time here and OMG AMAZING loved it so much ??? wet burritos awesome ??? evwn my husband loved it we well definitely be eating here more often in my opinion the owner should be very proud of there