Reviews
What Michael Schuett doesn't like about Papa's Tomato Pies:
How special can spaghetti and meatballs be? The meatballs were very good. The spaghetti sauce leaves much room for improvement. But then again, they are a pizza palour and probably using one sauce to fit all. Overall it was a pleasuse. View all feedback. What User likes about Papa's Tomato Pies:
Excellent pizza. The first time we tried Papa's tomato pieces. The pizza was excellent. We ordered a regular pizza with mushrooms. The pizza was good and had a good crispy crust. Cheese and toppings were delicious. We also ordered the mustard cake. It's the first time to try a mustard cake, but it was pretty good. It reminded me to eat a pulp with spicy mustard. One thing I really loved is that they serve RC cola. It... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
How special can spaghetti and meatballs be? The meatballs were very good. The spaghetti sauce leaves much room for improvement. But then again, they are a pizza...
read moreMustard Pie? Mind BLOWN! I NEVER would have thought that Mustard on PIZZA was actually DELICIOUS! Never say Never! Thank you Papa’s, your pizza was fantastic. I...
read moreMustard Pie for my birthday with my sons great gift !
Best Tomato pie in the area!! A must try for everyone
The best pizza I have ever had. We don't live in the area, but whenever we are in the vicinity of the place we stop in and have dinner and then order to take pi...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreExcellent pizza. The first time we tried Papa's tomato pieces. The pizza was excellent. We ordered a regular pizza with mushrooms. The pizza was good and had a...
read moreThis place was highly recommended. You were 100% right. The pizza is one of the best I ever had and that includes the original Frank Pepe. The Bruschetta was de...
read moreThis last Tuesday, 5 July. 2020 after 1st Leg of a group motorcycle ride with friends, considered here one of the best Trenton tomato pies known Old School Pizz...
read moreWonderful jewel of a restaurant! Our server Ruby has made an excellent recommendation to add to the mustard sausage - yes, you have heard that right pizza that...
read moreThis is my favorite pizza place in existence! That mustard pizza was just fantastic. The wings were odd. They were a little sweet/tangy and crispy. Not a flavor...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreFrom a New Yorker, this place is 5/5 Fresh, thin crust, and very tasty pizza. I can eat a full pie (it's pretty light) Service is excellent and it's a very home...
read moreI heard from a friend that there was a Trenton-style pizza (but also a mustard pizza), I knew I had to make the long drive to Papa's. I really liked the sweet c...
read moreUpdating my review as promised- the bang bang shrimp was delicious and I would definitely get it again! The little bread pieces the shrimp were on were nice and...
read moreI give them a 9/10. Great experience and family run business. Very old school booths and seating, along with the old school service and Italian feel inside. Fir...
read morePerfect pizza every time. thin crust, great sauce, no flop. The mustard pie is a thing of wonder. Every topping is top flight, the salads are awesome. Papa's is...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more