Images
ContributeNo images to show
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Beth Jarvie likes about Bagels N Cream:
The bagels here are fantastic, and the service is outstanding! They also play great music while you wait. Just a heads up: it's cash only. I recently visited and forgot about the cash-only policy, but luckily the bill was exactly the amount of cash I had on me. The staff member returned a dollar to me and said he couldn’t let me leave with an empty wallet. What a classy move! This has definitely become my favorite ba... View all feedback.
What Doug Kennedy doesn't like about Bagels N Cream:
The best bagels around, but the service is terrible. They constantly mess up orders (including online orders), ignore in-person customers for online orders, blast music so no one can hear anything, and refuse to honor their own coupons View all feedback.
There's always a long wait, the bagels were served untoasted, and the amount of butter was excessive.
I wish I had known that the omelette contained mushrooms because I dislike them and would have asked for it without. Aren't mushrooms considered a fungus rather than a vegetable?
The baklava here is the best! While all of their food is incredible, I can't get enough of the baklava. The service is excellent, and the staff are wonderful!
BAGELS AND CREAM IS THE BEST EVAAAAA (but i do miss caesar and wish theyd be friends again :
Best bagels and bagel sandwiches in the area, if not central Jersey altogether. Do yourself favor and grab theyre signature blueberry crunch bagel while youre there. I see a few people with order issues, but in 25 years of coming here, theyve never gotten an order wrong in person, on the phone, or online. They clearly have the doordash menu set up improperly. Example being sub roll as a free option in a bagel sandwich, when the sub roll version is $4 more in reality, so they just give it to you on the bagel instead of losing money. Its a matter of not getting the technology correct, not being stooges. I know it still sucks to not get what you ordered.
Full Menu
More information
QR-code link to the menu
