Spicy's - Riverhead

American, Barbecue, Pasta

Spicy's

Spicy's
4.0 / 5 (2008 reviews)

Description

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Marina

Feedback

★ 4 / 5 from 2008 reviews
white-alexandre
13.04.2023

I probably shouldn't have dug into my meal before taking a photo, but sweet potato cake is my weakness. Spicy is a bit of a trek from Southampton, but it's definitely worth it. When we arrived, some NYU students left despite the SHE (I'm guessing it's a local term or reference). There was a line that wasn't quite out the door. We placed our order and then went to a nearby bodega that also had a tempting hot food selection worth checking out. The woman absolutely loved the grill; they deserve a five-star rating. As for me, I've had better cake, but not while in the Hamptons.

hickle-roberta
13.04.2023

This little BBQ spot is incredible! You can either take out or dine in, and the food is simple yet perfectly cooked. It's flavorful and rich without being greasy. I also tried their amazing fried fish sandwich, which I paired with salad, tomatoes, American cheese, and tartar sauce. Definitely support this small business; it's well worth it!

sipes-marina
13.04.2023

Back to my list of places to eat love of Mac salad and dipped chicken sandwich. Great prices.

sipes-marina
13.04.2023

"Sure, it’s a bit of a dive and most of the dishes are fried, but wow, it's really delicious! We ordered the rib dinner and the chicken dinner, both of which come with green salad and macaroni salad. My friend had 10 wings, and I had a side of macaroni and cheese. The standout was definitely the golden BBQ sauce! The fries and onion rings were also quite tasty."

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.