Buoy One - Feedback

The best fried fish plates. This is a hidden jewel... An actual fish market that has a seating area in the indoor/outdoor area. I'm here twice and the fried fis...

I have eaten here a few times and the food is always great. Recently ate here with a large party including kids. The service was amazing. Our waitress Claire wa...

I read all GREAT reviews. I ate here years ago and was not impressed. I thought I should try again. They lived up to their reputation. The food was delicious. N...

The food was good. Fisherman's record. But I went there at 7:00, so I understand.

I ate at the buoy on Wednesday my sister and I had the fried oyster platter. It was pretty good. However I got the seafood chowder to go. I was disappointed as...

Delicious !! Amazing waitress, so sweet and helpful. We stopped in on our way back from montauk, might try to stop by again next time!

This is really painful as, for years, Buoy One was my favorite restaurant on Long Island. We would alternate between the Riverhead and Westhampton locations and...

Solid seafood spot! Tried the oyster basket and the seafood basket. The seafood basket was much more substantial but both were filling and I still had leftovers...

10/4/23 Getting ready to head out of town we decided to have our favorite Thai cod at Buoy One. Tonya met us at the door and knew exactly what we wanted to eat....

Let's be honest, the exterior of this place may not be much to look at in the early spring and end of winter, but once inside, it's actually quite charming. It'...

During our vacation from California, we made a stop at this restaurant after visiting the outlets. The oyster appetizer was delicious and the Manhattan chowder...

This restaurant serves the best fried fish platters. It's a hidden gem with an indoor and outdoor seating area. I've been here twice and the fried fish basket i...