Pie R Square - Feedback

Grocery, In-store Pick-up, Bakery

Reviews

Overall Total Score
4.7 out of 5
Outstanding | 52 reviews

Was Wendy C at Pie R Square a mag?
I ordered two pot pies, a quiche, and an apple pie, and each item was delicious. They had great flavor, and even after reheating, they stayed moist and flavorful. I’ll definitely be coming back—I don't know why I waited so long to try this place! View all feedback.

What Rod R dislikes about Pie R Square:
Not bad but not special. I tried the Dutch apple pie and the sweet potato pie. Horrible value as I've had better pies from the grocery store for a third of the price. The crust was not particularly flaky and it was undercooked as if they were in a rush. If I'm paying $80 for 3 standard sized pies, they should be amazing. They were not. Costco pies are bigger and better. View all feedback.

Reviews from various websites

Restaurantji

Last update : 13.11.2023

4.7 ★ from 52 reviews
judy-blasdell
judy 13.11.2023 - 09:45

Daughter and I just noticed this little pie shop. Went up the road, made a uturn, came back and bought a mini Chocolate pie. Soooooo good. Will go back for more next week. At least 4 :

ryan-e-doctor7060
Ryan 13.11.2023 - 09:45

Pie R Square made 100 mini pies for our wedding and it was a huge it! The service and delivery process was super easy and the pies were amazing. Thanks for showing our friends and family how we do dessert in Chattanooga!

ray-johnson-4
Ray 13.11.2023 - 09:45

All 4 pies I bought were personal size and delicious. They have quiche, I'll go back and get some. This is real homemade goodies.

rod-r-snake8948
Rod 13.11.2023 - 09:45

Not bad but not special. I tried the Dutch apple pie and the sweet potato pie. Horrible value as I've had better pies from the grocery store for a third of the price. The crust was not particularly flaky and it was undercooked as if they were in a rush. If I'm paying $80 for 3 standard sized pies, they should be amazing. They were not. Costco pies are bigger and better.

jay-olsen-thrift
Jay 13.11.2023 - 09:45

Both their savory and sweet pies are fantastic. Love the wide selection to choose from as well.

Good Rated Restaurants near Red Bank