Nancy's Towne House - Rahway

The only disappointing aspect of my experience was that when I called in to place a pickup order, the woman estimated a 40-minute wait. However, when I arrived to pick up my two pizzas, they weren't as hot as I expected – if 1 is cold and 10 is straight from the oven hot, I’d rate them a 6. It seemed like they were ready much sooner than the 40 minutes she mentioned, so they may have sat out for a little while. That said, the pizza tasted great and had a nice crispy texture. Maybe next time I’ll just dine in.

Superb pizza with very friendly and accommodating staff!!

I ordered two pies because of the hype surrounding them. The reviews were quite intriguing. This is the thinnest crust pizza I’ve ever had—definitely unique. It was really good, but quite different from what I expected. I also tried the meat pie, which was excellent. As for the plain large pizza, I gave it an 8.2 after one bite. Overall, a great experience!

The pizza here is too thin for the price you pay. If you’re after a doughy crust, look elsewhere. While Dave described it as light and airy, what I got was a crunchy, overcooked, and oversauced pie that really needed more cheese along the edges. The service varies significantly depending on whether the staff knows you or your companions, which feels unprofessional. The restaurant's decor is outdated and could use a complete revamp. On the bright side, the drinks are good—though it's hard to mess up sangria or basic cocktails. Just a heads up: if the parking lot is full, you’ll have to pay for street parking or use the lot across the street.

One of the best thin crust pizzas you will eat. Has been a great place to go for many years!