Herfy's - Puyallup

Burgers, Fast Food, American
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Herfy's

Herfy's
3.9 / 5 (783 reviews)

Menu

A comprehensive menu of Herfy's from Puyallup featuring all 126 dishes and drinks can be found here on the menu.

This restaurant in Orting has received mixed reviews from customers. While some have had negative experiences with the owner, others have praised the great food and service. One customer had a dispute over missing cheese on their burger, leading to a confrontation with the owner. However, other customers have had positive experiences, with one person even receiving free bacon on their burger combo. The food quality has received mixed reviews, with some saying it doesn't taste like it used to in the 80s, while others have enjoyed dishes like the triple burger and shrimp burger. The staff have been described as friendly and professional by some customers, making it a great spot for a quick lunch or dinner. Overall, this restaurant seems to have both fans and critics, so it might be worth a try to form your own opinion.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Maleah

Images

Herfy's Food Herfy's Food Herfy's Menu Herfy's Menu Herfy's Food Herfy's Inside Herfy's Food Herfy's Food

Feedback

★ 3.9 / 5 from 783 reviews

Was Austin Abraham at Herfy's a mag?
The food was great and the quantity’s are large. Staff if very kind and accommodating. Service: Take out Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4 Recommended dishes: Burger View all feedback.

What Misty Barber dislikes about Herfy's:
I will not return to this fast food place. Their burgers had a weird taste. I did not take more than a couple bites before throwing it out. The french fries were good but they're fry sauce was not. I was going to get fish and chips for my niece but it was very overpriced at around $16 for a basic fish and chips. I definitely do not recommend this place to eat. View all feedback.

nick-stone
15.11.2023

Went in to get a Single Cheeseburger Combo, and the lady at the counter informed me that I could get the bacon single cheeseburger combo for the same price. Free bacon! I thought this was very nice to see. Highly recommend this restaurant. Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch

carol-manriquez
15.11.2023

The service is great. The food is outstanding. You definitely get what you pay for. It's the best place for great food. Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20

tina-tucker-2
15.11.2023

DO NOT EAT HERE!! Kim is no good and does not need to be in business!! i mean wow treating ppl the way she does. i will never go there again!! I have been coming to this place once every few months and really had no major complaints except that its priced to high for a burger but I went 9-19-23 got the same burger the Swiss mushroom burger like always this time I wasn't able to eat it until later in the night but found out they forgot to put the cheese on it so I call the next day talk to kim she tells me I should have took a pic or left a message but she agrees to give me my money back so I go down there from graham and she tells me that she will not give me the money back and tells me I have to leave the restaurant she was very combative like I was the wrong one but it was not only me they did it to I was with my mother that ordered food for her friend which was wrong they marked the burgers wrong plus no cheese on theirs as well this place is very wrong hiring young boys that don't pay attention and she wasnt even there to know what was going on then she treating customers like they where wrong I never take pictures of my food and have never had anyone tell me I should take pictures for proof that is crazy what about the customers always right I mean wow she really doesn't need to be in business treating ppl like that I will never go back and ill be letting everyone know it's the worst place in Orting to eat!! she should have never told me she would give me my money back then make me go all the way down there to be treated with such disrespect and be told to leave im disable and its hard for me to get around this was not easy for me i dont go out much but when i do i deserve good service just like eveyone else. In reference to ur comment I did not change my story it was as i stated no swiss cheese on the buger just because the cheese is put on meat does not mean that u cant tell. There was NO CHEESE!! There was no taste to the thing the swiss is what makes it have flavor. when I called I didn't ask for a refund i was thinkig it would be replaced but u insisted u would give me a refund and like I said I didn't even eat the thing until 9:00pm that night and the restaurant was closed i did call but u seem to need proof and I didn't think oh i better take a picture for u as im not in a habit of doing so. Ive never had somone just call me a lier like that not believe what i was saying never thought i needed proof for someone like this but i did tell u that from now on u can bet i will take pictures if i have any issue else where u tought me that as for my mother she had nothing to do with it this was between u and I although she had the same issue because we came in together but ordered separately u where not there u have no idea what went on u would not even listen to us u acted like we was trying to steal from u. u where yelling and ordered us to leave the restaurant did not even hear our side so u have no idea what the problem really is!! in fact the young man was so frazzled he wasn't sure he gave the receipts. He gave one but not the other we had to ask for it and i will not take that comment out maybe they need to stick with shcool cause they r forgetting to much at work sounds like they r doing to much cant keep up!!

maleah-missmaleah
07.03.2025

Service: Dine in Meal type: Other Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Fried Shrimp, Fish Chips, Fish Burger, Sauce, Fried Fish, Fish 'N Chips

im-ungabunga
07.03.2025

Yummy food and great service!! Service: Take out Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Onion Rings, Burger, Sauce, Fries

  • Specialty Burgers

    Oregon's Best Homemade Gourmet Burger
    Oregon's Best Homemade Gourmet Burger
    $10.4
    Philly Cheese Steak Beef Or Chicken
    Philly Cheese Steak Beef Or Chicken
    $14.2
    Mushroom Burger (With Swiss)
    Mushroom Burger (With Swiss)
    $11.8
  • Sandwiches

    French Dip (On French Roll)
    French Dip (On French Roll)
    $11.5
  • Drinks

    Milkshakes & Root Beer Floats
    Milkshakes & Root Beer Floats
    $5.9
  • Mains

    Roasted Beef Burger
    Roasted Beef Burger
    $11.8

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.