Goat Soup Whiskey - Feedback

The perch tacos are absolutely the best on the entire island. I make a trip here every year, and it wouldn’t be the same without indulging in the perch tacos an... read more The perch tacos are absolutely the best on the entire island. I make a trip here every year, and it wouldn’t be the same without indulging in the perch tacos and a sazerac. Their drink menu is also exceptional. After our seventh visit, I can confidently say that the perch tacos remain the finest in the area!

The mussels were incredible. We also tried three different soups, and you could really taste the high-quality ingredients—they definitely weren't from a can. read more The mussels were incredible. We also tried three different soups, and you could really taste the high-quality ingredients—they definitely weren't from a can.

A peaceful spot to dine, featuring a fantastic staff and delicious food. read more A peaceful spot to dine, featuring a fantastic staff and delicious food.

Was told they had really good bloody Marys and it was just ok. Took forever to get service and it felt like we were judged by what we were wearing didn't end up... read more Was told they had really good bloody Marys and it was just ok. Took forever to get service and it felt like we were judged by what we were wearing didn't end up ordering lunch there did have appetizers that were just ok. We should have had a beer and pretzel outside instead

Excellent we arrived a little before our reservation and was quickly seated. Katie our server was wonderful. read more Excellent we arrived a little before our reservation and was quickly seated. Katie our server was wonderful.

This place was AMAZING!! Service was outstanding and the menu selection is great! One of the best meals I've had at a restaurant!! It's a must do if you're on t... read more This place was AMAZING!! Service was outstanding and the menu selection is great! One of the best meals I've had at a restaurant!! It's a must do if you're on the island

I always enjoy visiting the Goat when I'm in PIB. The food is excellent, the service is fantastic, and the atmosphere is wonderful. read more I always enjoy visiting the Goat when I'm in PIB. The food is excellent, the service is fantastic, and the atmosphere is wonderful.

Love this place! The food is so good and the atmosphere is very pleasant. read more Love this place! The food is so good and the atmosphere is very pleasant.

The Goat would be very enjoyable if workers didn't bring their children who do not know how to behave in public and wives to work. The atmosphere was totally ru... read more The Goat would be very enjoyable if workers didn't bring their children who do not know how to behave in public and wives to work. The atmosphere was totally ruined with the mom who was either not paying attention to her ill behaved children or putting water on them to discipline them.

Be sure to make a reservation! When our group of four arrived, we gave our name and were quickly seated in a beautiful spot with a fantastic view. Our server wa... read more Be sure to make a reservation! When our group of four arrived, we gave our name and were quickly seated in a beautiful spot with a fantastic view. Our server was very attentive and provided great recommendations. I tried the Mediterranean veggie naan, and it was incredibly tasty! I really wish they had a Goat Soup and Whiskey on the menu so I could enjoy it again soon. Everyone in my group loved their meals!

This was probably the best meal I've had in a long time. Everything was just perfect. I ordered the beet salad and the fish taco, while my partner chose the hal... read more This was probably the best meal I've had in a long time. Everything was just perfect. I ordered the beet salad and the fish taco, while my partner chose the half salad with a selection of two soups. It was a fantastic lunch in a wonderful atmosphere.

Great place for dinner, both entrees and appetizer were good. Had a marvelous Key Lime Martini! The service was excellent. If you are wanting to dine here defin... read more Great place for dinner, both entrees and appetizer were good. Had a marvelous Key Lime Martini! The service was excellent. If you are wanting to dine here definitely make reservations, it's worth it.

The best food on Put-in-Bay, hands down. And the best espresso martini I've ever had in my entire life. The clam chowder was the best I've ever had as well. Lar... read more The best food on Put-in-Bay, hands down. And the best espresso martini I've ever had in my entire life. The clam chowder was the best I've ever had as well. Large variety of options on the menu. Lovely patio area for outdoor dining. I make it a point to always visit here when I'm on the island. Can't wait to go back!

YUMMMMM! I absolutely loved the ambiance of this stunning restaurant and was pleasantly surprised to discover that the food was just as fantastic! I appreciated... read more YUMMMMM! I absolutely loved the ambiance of this stunning restaurant and was pleasantly surprised to discover that the food was just as fantastic! I appreciated that the menu wasn't overly extensive, which shows they prioritize quality over quantity. Our lively group enjoyed the outdoor patio while sipping on refreshing cocktails, and I have to say, the blueberry mint mojito was hands down the best drink we ordered! I loved that it wasn't overly sweet. We all chose different dishes, but the overwhelming favorite was the perch tacos. There weren't many vegan or vegetarian options, so I opted for a reuben without the corned beef, served with beer-battered fries. Delicious! It was a bit of an unusual order, but the server was more than accommodating with my special request. Speaking of the service, our server was absolutely delightful—attentive, funny, and she reminded me a bit of Amy Schumer—adorable! I would highly recommend Goat!

We had an amazing dining experience tonight! I loved the escargot and managed to convince my friends to try them after a bit of persuasion—they ended up loving... read more We had an amazing dining experience tonight! I loved the escargot and managed to convince my friends to try them after a bit of persuasion—they ended up loving them too. I also ordered the chicken marsala and the Walleye Oscar, both of which were fantastic. I was very pleased with both the food and the service, and I would definitely be happy to return.

The restaurant was extraordinary and definitely justified its price. It boasts an elegant atmosphere and serves filet mignon that practically melts in your mout... read more The restaurant was extraordinary and definitely justified its price. It boasts an elegant atmosphere and serves filet mignon that practically melts in your mouth, alongside perfectly al dente vegetables and a delightful baked potato. The bread was exceptional, and the service was top-notch. If you're looking for a remarkable dining experience, this is the place to be—just be ready to spend a bit. Additionally, there are two shops on the lower level worth checking out, one specializing in chocolate and the other in German delicacies.

This restaurant was the perfect choice for our bachelorette party! We received excellent service and enjoyed delicious food. The tortilla soup was outstanding,... read more This restaurant was the perfect choice for our bachelorette party! We received excellent service and enjoyed delicious food. The tortilla soup was outstanding, and my fish tacos were just as delightful. We shared a variety of appetizers, and everyone was raving about how amazing everything tasted. With a group of about 20, we all left feeling very impressed. The staff was incredibly friendly and accommodating to our large party, too. Just a heads-up—this place now only takes reservations, so make sure to plan ahead!

I dined at this restaurant for the first time during my stay on the island. The lamb chops were prepared medium, but I wasn’t particularly impressed with them.... read more I dined at this restaurant for the first time during my stay on the island. The lamb chops were prepared medium, but I wasn’t particularly impressed with them. The fries and tater tots were a bit too salty for my taste. The shrimp po'boys were enjoyable, but the pierogi filled with pasta were just okay. On the bright side, the Thai crunch salad was quite tasty. The drinks were also pleasant, but I found that the outdoor seating wasn’t suitable for large groups, though it was a lovely spot to soak in the outdoor ambiance.

It was probably the best meal I've had in a long time. Everything was just perfect. I ordered the beet salad and fish taco, while my husband chose the half sala... read more It was probably the best meal I've had in a long time. Everything was just perfect. I ordered the beet salad and fish taco, while my husband chose the half salad with two soup options. We had a delightful lunch in a lovely atmosphere.