Sarah L Defelice Pizza House

My family has been getting pizza from Mrs. Defelice since I was a little girl in the 60s. It's not a fancy pizza, only comes with pepperoni (and not very much, at that). But the sauce and the cheese blend is something me, my children, my siblings, my parents, my cousins, everyone in the family, just CRAVE. None of the family live in Punxsy anymore but when we come to town, we always order massive quantities. Always.

I haven’t had your pizza since I was a kid mention sweet sauce taste

Tucked away on a side residential street you will find this Hometown Secret.You can't Truely experience the whole Home of Punxsutawney Phil adventure without having eaten a Sarah Pie or a Sarah Slapper as they are know to the locals.They'll have your taste buds thanking you..

Just wish you had a ramp for those who have problems with steps. Love this pie.

This restaurant serves the best pizza in Punxsutawney, no question! I grew up eating these pizzas and now that I live in Texas, I miss them. Whenever I come back home, I always make sure to stop by and get one. The pizzas are absolutely fantastic.