Cosimo's - Poughkeepsie

I was really disappointed with the $17 Chicken Chop Chop salad. It didn’t have any bacon, just a few small tomatoes and only a handful of chickpeas. The whole e... read more I was really disappointed with the $17 Chicken Chop Chop salad. It didn’t have any bacon, just a few small tomatoes and only a handful of chickpeas. The whole egg was green inside and not sliced, and the chicken was dry. The worst part was when I called to complain, I was told that they couldn't offer a refund since it was a DoorDash order. I appreciate the offer of a free dessert coupon, but I'd rather skip it to avoid any risk of food poisoning.

I absolutely love the food here, but I really dislike trying to find parking during lunchtime when I go to pick up my order. This is the only place in the area... read more I absolutely love the food here, but I really dislike trying to find parking during lunchtime when I go to pick up my order. This is the only place in the area where I’ll buy Fried Calamari—it always comes out perfectly and I’ve never been disappointed. I also tried the Romano Chicken Chop Chop Salad for the first time, and it was a generous portion that I shared with others. It was bursting with flavor, and I will definitely be ordering it again.

The Warm Chocolate Lava Cake was quite small and arrived cold (which is understandable for delivery). However, after I heated it up, it turned out to be solid w... read more The Warm Chocolate Lava Cake was quite small and arrived cold (which is understandable for delivery). However, after I heated it up, it turned out to be solid with no gooey chocolate center as one would expect. The ice cream that accompanied it was delicious, but at $9, I probably won't be ordering it again.

Great portion. Shrimp were delicious read more Great portion. Shrimp were delicious

Went for lunch with a friend on Weds. 2/16 and was impressed to see so many patrons and warm welcome. For some reason our order was never entered and due to the... read more Went for lunch with a friend on Weds. 2/16 and was impressed to see so many patrons and warm welcome. For some reason our order was never entered and due to the delay it was on the house. Waiter was apologetic and we were perfectly fine with as we were eating the olive bread and conversing. The food was delicious and well worth the wait. 5 stars and I highly recommend and will return and/or visit one of their other locations.