Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Shelly N likes about Cimaroli's Supper Club:
I have GREAT childhood memories of Cimaroli's and accompanying my elder parents, aunts and uncles. Fast forward to this past Mother's Day, I could not make the trip to spend with my Mom but ROBIN made a miracle happen by allowing me to make a payment over the phone for my Mother and brother's meal, and surprise them it did! It was a lot to ask of her since she had to identify this pair from my description that was a... View all feedback.
What Greg Calhoun doesn't like about Cimaroli's Supper Club:
Got my first bad meal in over 20 years going here. We ordered Prime Rib med rare it came out well done and look like it was cooked a week ago. I swear ,I bet they used a microwave for our whole meal ,nothing seemed fresh, Very disappointing for the money you pay. Don't know if I will return. View all feedback.
Great find for our group of 10! Service was excellent, food even better. There were no complaints from any of our large party. This has never happened before. The variety of old-fashioned cocktails is perfect for this supper club. There is even an outdoor bar. We would have loved to stay if it didn't rain. Will definitely be back.
Great old school supper club feel good old-fashions
Beefy prime rib weighing in at 32oz for the Hubs and I had the 16 oz flatiron steak that they are famous for. We will.prob have 2 more meals on the leftovers but the pricing just made sense. Both tender and full of flavor. Our 3rd visit t I Cimarollis and we are just as impressed as our first visit. They just do it all so well. $4.00 old fashioneds! We will be back!
Amazing food. Outstanding service. And strong Old Fashions. Best supper club in Wisconsin.
Everything was outstanding, from food quality to serving size, as well the service was very friendly and quick. Also the restaurant cleanliness was beautiful!! My wife and I were celebrating our birthdays and it was a great experience!
More information
QR-code link to the menu
