Twilight Cafe Pj - PORT JEFFERSON

We love amazing olives. At the first visit I went with my mother and sister who are out of town. We were greeted with a smile and said that we could try as many as we want. We tried a few and bought some as gifts. I asked about their custom labels knowing that my friend had a birthday in a week. You said no problem! It came out great! My second trip was to pick them up and buy a gift certificate, knowing that he wanted to vote the visit and try it himself! Today we made this trip, again greeted for the third time with a smile. We tried so many, spent a while and then bought some fig balsamika, Jalapeño white balsamico and a Tuscan olive oil. And some tasting dishes. We are so excited to try each one of them and when we're done, I'm sure we'll be back for more. Great for gifts, wedding/baby showers, hosts, so many reasons to come to visit.

Great little place. Everyone was very helpful. Drink before you buy. Various flavored oils and vinegar available in different sizes. Also have the possibility to buy the bottle for party gift with custom pictures and lettering.

The amazing olive is really amazing! The owner, Candy, was knowledgeable, attentive and incredibly helpful when it comes to creating custom gifts for me. She made three impeccable baskets and included alcohol that I added as a supplement. Everything was nice. Can't recommend this place enough!

I and the family visited here on Friday before we went to Joey's Z next door. The amount of different kinds of olive oil is amazing! Huge selection, and the place feels very cozy. I have the Scorpion Hot Sauce from here, it is very hot and very tasteful. I always use it. Remember to come back to the ferry and more of this haha!

Staff is super friendly and knowledgeable. Great products as well. They even have a loyalty program which helps bc it is a bit pricey.