Captain Phantasy's Amici's Pizzeria

Delicious homemade pizza vibes. Ingredients tasted fresh and the pie was amazing!Will be back many more times in the future, highly recommend trying this gem out.

I've had almost every pizza offered in Port Charlotte and Punta Gorda. This might be my new favorite. I ordered online and the pizza was wonderful. Thin crust and cooked perfectly. Best I've had in 5 years. Can't wait to try some of their menu items. Ingredients were fresh.

Stopped in to have lunch and it's a takeout only. Instead of the pizza we ordered the foot subs: one chicken parm and a meatball sub. I had mine cut into quarters thinking 3-4 meatballs and at least one per quarter. Lettuce and tomato, too. When I got home and opened it it had tiny little pieces of meat. Meatballs? I have no idea. Each time I picked up a quarter to take a bite the diced meat pieces fell out! I honestly can't say it was a meatball sub. I couldn't even enjoy a decent bite of meatball and sauce because it fell out. Service was excellent... the idea to dice up the meatballs and fill a sub for a meatball sub? Not such a good idea! I craved a meatball sub with sauce, lettuce and tomatoes and I got a minced meat mess!

The White Pizza is to die for. Not on the regular menu, you need to call and order it.

Sorry, but this place is now terrible since changing to Captain Phantasy 's . My pizza was delivered literally ten minutes after ordering. Why is this bad? Because that means it was not a freshly cooked pizza since it takes ten minutes to drive from there to my house. Also the cannoli was the worst tasting I 've ever had in my life. Never again!