Pj's Deli - Pomeroy

Pizza, Delis, Steak

Pj's Deli

Pj's Deli
3.8 / 5 (910 reviews)

Description

**Restaurant Review: A Mixed Bag at PJ's Deli**

While some patrons enjoy nostalgic visits for cheesesteaks and strombolis, others express frustration over order accuracy and food quality. Issues like receiving incorrect items, such as soggy wraps and disappointing pizzas with minimal toppings, have led to dissatisfaction among some customers. However, the welcoming atmosphere and friendly service have kept loyal fans returning. With no indoor seating and an amusing Santa mannequin, PJ’s cultivates a unique charm that resonates with many. Overall, while the food experience may vary, the hospitality and homey vibe create a memorable dining option for locals and travelers alike.

Last update: 21.05.2026 from: Patricia

Feedback

★ 3.8 / 5 from 910 reviews
braided-up-one
16.11.2023

The cheesesteak with the sweet sauce is amazing! I really love their food.

colleen-mullen-1
16.11.2023

These are the best cheesesteak egg rolls I've ever had! They're absolutely perfect for game day. Go Birds!

jason-gill-2
16.11.2023

I can't quite put my finger on it. Most sandwich shops seem very similar, yet I keep coming back to this one. There’s no seating inside, which I actually appreciate. You just order, pay, and go. However, there is a rather eerie Santa mannequin that seems to watch you while you wait for your food. And as a fun twist, if you look closely, you can spot a photo of the owner (I think) with pink hair hidden behind that mischievous Santa!

patricia-f-weed166
21.05.2026

No masks during a deadly pandemic. Breathing all over people's food while making it. I know of people who have died! My daughter is a nurse and has seen young, healthy people lose limbs because of covid. And these people don't have the basic decency to at least try to protect their customers. Haven't been there in years. NEVER going back!!

donald-wertz-1
21.05.2026

Very excellent food you won't be disappointed best cheesy steak in the area

FAQ

The diner and its premises are wheelchair accessible and thus reachable with a wheelchair or physiological limitations.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.