Pie Guy's Pizzeria - Picton

Wow. Simply wow. I have had their hot wings before and I always recommend them to everyone. However, since trying their pizza for the first time, all I can say is "holy cow." The taste is amazing and even the presentation of the food is like a work of art. Hands down, this is the best pizza shop in the county. (My uncle is married to the owner of another pizza shop in the city, so I do not say this lightly.) I highly recommend it to anyone.

SCAM ALERT! Avoid. Pizza is overpriced for the quality. Extremely soggy and bland… chicken wings are unusually expensive when you arrive to pay even though the website says $13/pound. Scam alert!

Charged $8 more for chicken wings than the stated price on the menu. I was not advised of the price increase until I looked at the amount on my debit card. Then he said he had to charge more because a bag of wings cost $200. The fries were an additional $10. I paid $32 for 8 wings and fries. I had no choice because no other food establishments were open when we arrived in Picton and were looking for restaurants at 9pm. Both the owner and the employee were extremely rude. Acted like they were doing us a favor for providing food. Friends got a pizza and paid an arm leg for that too. The food was ok but certainly not worth the prices we paid. Bags of foul smelling garbage right beside the take out window gross!! I would never be able to recommend this dump!

Love this pizzeria! Not only was the owner very kind, the pizza cheesy bread were to die for!! I’d recommend anyone in Picton to give it a try. I’ll definitely be coming back for seconds ??

We came from out of town, and we found this was horrible overpriced pizza. Surprised we had such a bad experience because all the reviews were great. You’re better off going down the street to 555 brewing for amazing wood oven pizza and a pint