18th Amendment - Penn Yan

#24 - Pizza - Penn Yan, Distilleries, Cocktail

18th Amendment

18th Amendment
4.5 / 5 (412 reviews)

Menu

Here you will find the menu of 18th Amendment in Penn Yan. At the moment, there are 67 dishes and drinks on the menu.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Brett

Images

18th Amendment Menu 18th Amendment Inside 18th Amendment Food 18th Amendment Food 18th Amendment Drink 18th Amendment Food 18th Amendment Drink 18th Amendment Inside

Feedback

★ 4.5 / 5 from 412 reviews

Was John Duffy at 18th Amendment a mag?
Went here on a pretty busy night in Penn Yan as it was cruise in night for the first time in three years. Fortunately we made reservations and were seated immediately. We are at a different place in town the prior evening and we’re treated to good food, service and value. That restaurant was very basic and without frills. 18th is a bit of an outlier for the town. It’s exposed brick walls and black painted woodwork re... View all feedback.

What Petru Moga dislikes about 18th Amendment:
Expensive cocktails, but the food is generally excellent with one exception. The burger with bacon and blue yonder is the best ever, but the fries were soggy both times I tried them. Other dishes we’ve tried were lobster pasta, salmon, and roast pork tenderloin, all wonderful. View all feedback.

antonio-arias-4
14.03.2025

Penn Yan really needed a place like this for a date night! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

yen-gonczol-3
14.03.2025

Great food but even better service! Recommend the specials and the BLT deviled eggs! Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

25halfordfamily
14.03.2025

Best meal we have had in a long time. We used to live in NYC and this place would do well there, so that is saying a lot. Excellent service. The fish was amazing (a Mahi Mahi special), beautiful wedge salad, and slow roasted chicken with a Chimichurri sauce. A fantastic Weis wine from Keuka Lake and a really yummy special margarita, plus live music by a pianist. A special place and locally owned and operated. Service: Dine in

brett-gayhardt-fores
14.03.2025

Truly can 't say enough about how incredible this place is. Using fresh local ingredients, a cozy fun environment and the cocktails were out of this world good. The owner even took time to give me some tips of her own for creating simple syrups and how to mix certain drinks. We started with the fried green tomatoes and bean salad, then my wife got the Pen option for the night. Delicious Pork Sambuca with capers and perfectly season vegetables. I went with the Water option. Blackened shrimp and pumpkin gnocchi in a creole cream sauce with the perfect amount of warmth and kick. This was by far and away the best dining experience for our honeymoon. Every single time we 're even remotely close to the area, we 're coming back!!!

shannon-maine
14.03.2025

Stopped in for an after dinner cocktail and was absolutely delighted with the quality and attention to detail that is put into the craft beverages at this restaurant. Sat at the bar and received excellent service and had the bonus of having front row seats to the excellent craftsmanship that went into making the delicious and visually pleasing cocktails. Didn’t get food, but everything coming out of the kitchen looked and smelled outstanding. Strongly recommend this establishment if spending any time in the area.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.