Reviews - Gleason's
Reviews summary
Nestled in Peekskill, this restaurant draws both praise and criticism. While the food, especially the pizzas and pastas, receives compliments for being delicious and innovative, the service has sparked concerns among some patrons. Experiences vary widely, with tales of rudeness and inattentiveness overshadowing the culinary offerings at times. The inviting atmosphere and friendly bartenders promise a lively dining experience, particularly with live music. Though some recommend this spot for special occasions, others caution potential visitors about service inconsistency. For those willing to navigate these ups and downs, there is delicious gourmet fare waiting to be savored.
Reviews from various users
Last update : 19.04.2023
The food was outstanding and the service was excellent. We visited the night before Halloween before attending a show at the Paramount, and true to expectations, the restaurant was quite busy. Nonetheless, the server managed everything efficiently, our meal came quickly, and the pizza was fantastic!
The pasta at Gleason's is absolutely outstanding! The pizza was also delicious. However, the live music was quite loud and not very enjoyable. I recommend focusing on the fantastic Italian dishes or arriving before the music starts around 7:30.
Delicious, fresh dishes paired with warm and welcoming service—everything you could ask for!
The bartenders are friendly, the Auberginenparkkeil is excellent, the facility is inviting, and the seasonal cocktail list is creative. If you're not sure what to order, the staff always has great recommendations.
Large family or casual eating with fantastic gourmet pizza and design beer. enjoy an salad, child pizza (for 3 years old,) and 2 spezialpizzen. large wood fired crust with delicious veg and meat lover 12” cake. service was also fantastic, the evening meal enjoyed.
Last update : 17.06.2023
Cute and cozy outpost from the owners of Birdsall house. We enjoyed flavorful and strong cocktails, a fresh and tasty salad and a few appetizers, all great. I look forward to trying the pizza and entrees next time.
I've been to Gleason a lot. I always had a great time with great food. The cocktails are always innovative and delicious! The service was always top notch at the bar or table. I often find myself suggesting hanging with friends after work.
Gleason's is a fantastic restaurant to dine in. Their menu is filled with tasty pizza, appetizers, and more. If you haven't been there yet, you are definitely missing out. Give their meatballs a try and sample a specialty pizza. The staff is all very efficient and friendly.
I must say that my dining experience at Gleason's on Saturday night (3/10) was probably the best it has ever been. The food is consistently very good. I also want to give a shoutout to the bartender who served me; she was exceptionally nice and friendly.
I absolutely love this place. The octopus pizza is fantastic, the snacks are delicious, and the pasta is excellent. The service has always been wonderful, and I've dined here many times. It’s definitely a great spot to relax and enjoy a meal.
Last update : 24.03.2025
Friendly bartenders, excellent eggplant park wedge, love the welcoming decor, and a creative seasonal cocktail list. Not sure what to get? Always good recommendations from the staff.
A surprise for us, very loud, because very popular, live music that night, so much fun. Drinks are awesome and fun. Food is delicious. Wait staff tag teaming, always checking in on you. We will be back. An unexpected date night.
??????? The worst Customer Service experience ever!! We walked in at 10:34PM confirming with the security that pizza will be available (Keep in mind that we only went there for the pizza. Upon ordering immediately with the bartender, we waited about 30min for our order. It never showed up! So we asked the bartender what’s going on. To our ultimate surprise, the bartender whoclaimed to be the manager ultimately, was quite rude and kept interrupting us trying to shut us down. She rudely interrupted ourconversation between us and our friend and started yelling at us for addressing our situation Eventually, she said we were donefor the night and closed our tab because we were talking to our friends and told them what happened to our orders. As one of thenew property owner in this town, I felt extremely violated. We felt our tone of our skin(brown l played a major part in thebartenders behavior. We don’t play race cards but that’s the only conclusion we could’ve possibly came up with for thebartenders behavior! ??????????? We couldn’t believe how we was treated in this place. The worst!! We are extremelydisappointed. ????????
Great food. Great service, went the night before Halloween, prior to a show at the paramount, needless to say, it was packed. Despite this, the server handled everything, the food came out in a timely manner, the pizza was to die for!
Last update : 25.01.2024
I absolutely adore the penne alla vodka with chicken at this restaurant, it is simply amazing. The mozzarella sticks were also delicious and there is a wide variety of pizza options to choose from. I am a big fan of this place.
I always have a great time at Gleason's! This was my first visit to their new location and I absolutely love the atmosphere. The food is consistently delicious, and despite it being a...
Located in the former Hudson Room space, Gleason's is now bigger and better, offering excellent Comfort Food service. We opted not to try the signature pizzas...
