Amore Pizza - Paw Paw

The pizza and service were excellent! It felt a bit slow during our visit, but we were the only ones dining in at that time. I was pleasantly surprised by the low prices of their pizzas. They were delicious, and I will definitely return! Parking is limited as there's a small lot, but there are other nearby options available.

I ultimately decided to go in and pick up my order. Unfortunately, for the price I paid, I was quite disappointed with the food. We had ordered a Margherita pizza, but as you can see in the attached photo, that was not what we received. While I understand that my missed calls may have been an inconvenience, I felt the way I was treated was uncalled for, especially since my order hadn't even begun processing when I called back, and there was already a pending charge on my bank account. Given this experience, I won't be returning to Amores again.

The toppings were sparse, and the marinara sauce was overly watery. I found Pizza Hut to be a better option. The owner's responses to the reviews also say a lot about the establishment. I wouldn't recommend spending your money here!

Menu has eliminated many options, but what we had was good.

I always pass this little place on OTR runs to a local warehouse, and finally gave it a try. I live in the Syracuse, NY area and grew up on some of the finest Italian food ever, and I have to say that this reminds me of Home! SO glad I tried it, and will make the time to return every chance I can. Bravo, don't change a thing, you nailed it on the authentic!