Jimmy's Pizzeria - Feedback

Pizza is really good. Nice thin crust and good quality ingredients. The staff were really helpful and made a custom half and half pizza for me. My only suggesti... read more Pizza is really good. Nice thin crust and good quality ingredients. The staff were really helpful and made a custom half and half pizza for me. My only suggestion wud be more tomato sauce on the pepperoni and less blue cheese dressing on the buffalo chicken to balance the flavors.

Stopped in for the 2nd time in a month and the pizza was fantastic again. The new owner made me feel right at home. Ever since Marco's sold it went down hill, t... read more Stopped in for the 2nd time in a month and the pizza was fantastic again. The new owner made me feel right at home. Ever since Marco's sold it went down hill, the service, the food and the staff. I'm happy to say all.of those things and more are back. I live in NY and know pizza, try it out, you wont be disappointed.

I’ve been ordering from Joseph’s for several years. Great staff, owner recognizes me when he sees me, and great pizzas and salads! Something about tonight’s sau... read more I’ve been ordering from Joseph’s for several years. Great staff, owner recognizes me when he sees me, and great pizzas and salads! Something about tonight’s sausage and extra cheese pizza has an extra good taste to it. Throughout Covid I pay for my personal pizza and leave the rest in the jar to help out. Until tonight, because money is tight for me now. So I want to help another way and hopefully steer more folks to a great place!

Super thin and crispy pizza with a great team behind it. This is not your typical NYC/NJ pizza, but it's very good. Their crust is very thin and crispy, almost... read more Super thin and crispy pizza with a great team behind it. This is not your typical NYC/NJ pizza, but it's very good. Their crust is very thin and crispy, almost like a toasted pita/ flatbread. Their sauce is good and not overpowering. Their grandma pie is fantastic and full of flavor.

I showed up about 15 minutes before closing time. I know it’s usually not the best time to grab a slice but Jimmy’s pizzeria delivered. The gentleman behind the... read more I showed up about 15 minutes before closing time. I know it’s usually not the best time to grab a slice but Jimmy’s pizzeria delivered. The gentleman behind the counter heating up my slice and told me it was on the house. He was so damn cheerful at almost 10 o’clock at night! For being one of the last slices of the night it was surprisingly tasty! I will say I did in hell the slice and will definitely visit this location again. Highly recommend Jimmy‘s pizzeria.

The pizza at this restaurant is exceptional. The thin crust is beautiful and they use high-quality ingredients. The staff was very helpful and even made a custo... read more The pizza at this restaurant is exceptional. The thin crust is beautiful and they use high-quality ingredients. The staff was very helpful and even made a custom half pizza for me. My only suggestion would be to add more tomato sauce on the paprika pizza and less blue cheese dressing on the buffalo chicken pizza to balance the flavors.

The pizza at this restaurant is incredibly thin and crispy, made by a skilled team. It's different from the typical New York/New Jersey style pizza, but still d... read more The pizza at this restaurant is incredibly thin and crispy, made by a skilled team. It's different from the typical New York/New Jersey style pizza, but still delicious. The crust is thin and crispy, similar to a roasted pita or flatbread. The sauce is flavorful but not overpowering. The oma pie is especially delicious and packed with flavor.