Reviews - Biagio's

#5 - Seafood - Paramus, Italian, American

Reviews summary

Overall, the restaurant received mixed reviews. Some diners were disappointed with the quality of the food, citing issues such as cold starters, incorrect orders, and lackluster flavors. Service also seemed to be hit or miss, with some customers feeling rushed or uncomfortable due to the behavior of the waitstaff. However, there were positive comments about the outdoor seating and the freshness of the salads and burgers. Families with children appreciated the kids' buffet option, although some felt that the main dishes fell short of expectations. Despite the criticisms, many diners had a decent experience, with one standout mention of an excellent waiter. The restaurant may need to work on consistency in both food quality and service to ensure a better dining experience for all customers.

Overall Total Score
4 out of 5
Impressive | 10986 reviews

Images uploaded by reviewers

Reviews from various users

Menu

Last update : 01.04.2023

3.6 ★ from 63 reviews
andy-cormier
01.04.2023

Eating is excellent and plentiful hot hostess is the best. we will be back soon

margarita67
01.04.2023

The server was nice enough, but was very scattered. a bottle of wine from the beverage menu ordered. when I asked about other Pinot Grigios, the server said we had another list, but they have already selected and left it. he came back with the bottle, but the name was different from the menu. the server took the food order and one because later said to my man, they ordered ravioli or lasagne?, answer ravioli. the food was a little longer and the server brought lasagna to the house, it was like a comedy show. my chicken dish was good, but the menu had tomaten and it turned out, dried tomaten, great difference.

cremin-josefa
01.04.2023

All about great experience good food and service. Will definitely go back

gerhold-delmer
01.04.2023

We ordered a dip for an appetizer and it came with very limited chips, almost like the kitchen had run out. We ordered a mahi mahi off the specials menu and it was over cooked and fishy. We were surprised by the experience. The waiter didn’t even offer to take it off the menu. Just an unexpected visit.

esperanza55
31.10.2017

Biagio's is a local spot in my townI've been here a bunch of times for a multitude of reasons.

Opentable

Last update : 24.07.2024

4.4 ★ from 519 reviews
enjoydining
24.07.2024

Food was great. Waiter able to answer all questions appropriately

opentable-diner-183
24.07.2024

Always a great experience. The service and food is always top notch. The ownership is awesome.

opentable-diner-180
24.07.2024

Food was fantastic Linen napkins left hard to remove lint all over my clothes

kb9121
24.07.2024

Mediocre local Italian food. I was hoping for better. Food was ok, nothing great. Ambiance looks a little run down.

opentable-diner-182
24.07.2024

Food and the service were excellent. Thank you for a wonderful time.

Google

Last update : 14.03.2025

4.2 ★ from 1471 reviews
jose-rojas-3
14.03.2025

Highly advise to try the Chick Parm! Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 5

jackie-mcmahon-1
16.11.2023

Did my mother's repass here, had people from out of town that had to leave right away and they wouldn't give them a meal to go.I will never return to this place again. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 3 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 3

fern-chan-2
16.11.2023

The atmosphere was quite noisy, which detracted from the overall experience. **Service:** Dine-in **Meal Type:** Dinner **Price per person:** $50–100 **Food Rating:** 4/5 **Service Rating:** 4/5 **Atmosphere Rating:** 3/5 **Recommended Dishes:** Homemade Lobster Ravioli, Caesar Salad **Parking:** There is plenty of parking available, with options for a free parking lot and a free parking garage.

sheri-miller-library
16.11.2023

My wife and I had a wonderful date night at this restaurant. The food and service were excellent. The only downside was that the dining room is adjacent to the bar, which made it quite noisy. Despite that, I highly recommend this place. Service: Dine-in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50

mike-ryan-fern7202
16.11.2023

The steak was tough and overcooked, and the beet salad consisted of nothing but a few beets and a mound of ricotta. Overall, I would rate the food a 1.

Int Restaurants

Last update : 21.09.2023

4.1 ★ from 1998 reviews
elizabeth-sierra
21.09.2023

Was there today for Mother's Day (regular dining menu not the brunch special). Service was great! Food was outstanding! The mussels appetizer is the best I've had, and we (the adults in our group) devoured it! Special shout out to our server Tai (sorry if I spelled her name wrong) she was fantastic!

deya-vasallo-salvett
21.09.2023

Amazing birthday dinner tonight with the best service!!! Maitre D' Frank was on top of it all....never even had to call for a drink. Our server was top notch and Chef Jimmy went above and beyond. Thank You for making it a beautiful night.

lynn-garben-blasso
21.09.2023

The service and food here can't be beat!! We had a great meal of butternut squash ravioli. I highly recommend this restaurant if love great food and great service!!! We will come here often when In town for work.

maryann-vivolo-sclaf
21.09.2023

This is the absolute best place to have a party-large or small. Excellent food and service. I won't have parties anywhere else!!

roxanne-navarro
21.09.2023

First time there.. Loved the atmosphere, the waitress was exceptional. Each meal looked and tasted delicious. Can't wait to go again....

Yelp

Last update : 09.09.2023

3.4 ★ from 341 reviews
rosa-37
09.09.2023

I love this place - the service is always good and the food is consistently excellent. The staff at the bar are wonderful.

anthony-685
09.09.2023

The oysters were not properly shucked and the horseradish was dry. The calamari breading was coming off. The fresh mozzarella with smoked...

barbara-262
09.09.2023

Our favorite restaurant has changed. All of our meals were enjoyed at this restaurant. Despite being seated promptly and waiting for bread, it was disappointing that none was served even after the food arrived.

Facebook
4.0 ★ from 2001 reviews
Foursquare
3.9 ★ from 129 reviews
Tripadvisor
3.5 ★ from 160 reviews
Restaurantguru
4.1 ★ from 4304 reviews

FAQ

These Pictures from Biagio's in Paramus were contributed by the Menu community. They present the dining section at Biagio's, the interior design, the location and without a doubt, splendid Photographs of delicious dishes from Biagio's.

Good Rated Restaurants near Paramus