Captain Anderson's - Panama City

Local but first time dining here. Broiled seafood platter was flavorful but dry, except the fish and stuffed crab. I asked for my new york strip to be medium ra... read more Local but first time dining here. Broiled seafood platter was flavorful but dry, except the fish and stuffed crab. I asked for my new york strip to be medium rare, it was raw in middle, not medium rare. They served it with a gravy that was very good and I hate to say that's the only flavor the steak had. I can make a better steak on the grill at home. The hush puppies, fried cheese sticks and rolls were great. Those rolls are just perfect for soaking up any juices, chewy inside and crispy outside. Our server was very good, she was busy but didn't forget us and was pleasant. Besides dinner, the atmosphere was a lot to take in, the boats unloading their catch, the many bottles of wine in the glass room, lots of decor and the servers themselves weaving through the tables. We also enjoyed watching the cooks prepare and plate the food. Dinner and a show. We enjoyed our visit, but probably wouldn't return. Just too expensive for food that wasn't cooked right.

The restaurant is beautiful and it makes you feel like you're walking into a fancy ship. Our server Antonia was super friendly and very helpful. The Florida lob... read more The restaurant is beautiful and it makes you feel like you're walking into a fancy ship. Our server Antonia was super friendly and very helpful. The Florida lobster was delicious as well as their jumbo shrimp.

Always a great experience and food is consistently great. Staff and owners are over the top friendly. read more Always a great experience and food is consistently great. Staff and owners are over the top friendly.

Outstanding waiter!! Absolutely amazing food! Melt in your mouth steaks seafood perfectly grilled!! The restaurant is huge with a beautiful rustic interior desi... read more Outstanding waiter!! Absolutely amazing food! Melt in your mouth steaks seafood perfectly grilled!! The restaurant is huge with a beautiful rustic interior design which displays maritime antiquities from bygone eras. My family I rank our experiencethis evening with a perfect 10 have checked off Incredible Food Experience from our bucket List!!

I have been going here since I was a child. It is still a wonderful old florida experience. I had the stuffed grouper and crab finger appetizer. We don't eat ou... read more I have been going here since I was a child. It is still a wonderful old florida experience. I had the stuffed grouper and crab finger appetizer. We don't eat out very often so we went all out including a hurricane with a souvenir glass! Don't expect toget out without spending at least 100 for 2 people if you don't splurge like we did! It is first class everything though.