Nite Cap Inn - PALMYRA

On Friday, I arrived right when they opened at 4pm. There was a little crowd, and I was pleasantly surprised to see that there was a couple who arrived on horseback and tied up to the hitching post. (Yes, Nite Cap still has a hitching post for their guests! You place your order upon entering and then head to the bar to grab a drink and wait for your table to be ready. When they call your name, you get seated at your table to enjoy your family style, all-you-can-eat fish fry.? The fish was amazing! It completely lived up to the hype. I was surprised that it wasn’t a beer-batter, but the batter was still nice and crisp. The famous potato pancakes were also delicious! They weren’t greasy and had crispy edges and soft centers. I understand why the recipe has held the test of time! The meal also came with tartar, coleslaw, applesauce, and bread.?? Highly recommend a visit to Nite Cap Inn!

Only place I have ever been for all you can eat fish and was questioned when we wanted more. Received eye roll from waitress when we asked for more. 4 of us and she would bring 2 pieces at a time and they are the size of a playing card. Then we were told we were being wasteful. Finally Asked for 10 pieces as we had three grown men and my wife and she brought 7 and said that’s all they had. Took over an hour to eat a fish fry. If you are a big eater like the boys and I go somewhere else. They ran out of the house special beer and the cheese cake my Wife wanted. Fish was nothing special and potato pancakes tasted like they were from a box and were so tough you could barely cut them. Check reviews and You see a definite decline over the past few years. They need a lesson on getting customers to come back. Oh and don’t bother the hostess, she gets mad when you ask anything.

Drinks overpriced for country bar . 26 dollars for 1 jack and coke 1 rail rum and coke , 1 rail old fashioned , 1 can of coke and 1 soda of the gun . Saw review on top 20 fish fry . Fish was good if you could get any on family style . Coleslaw good . Potato pancakes tough but good flavor . Asked for french frys . One handful at a time . Disappointed from what the food critics said it would be . I will not tell anyone it's a must .

This is just the kind of place that needs to be preserved! Real homemade food, family run establishment. A true GEM!

Been here a couple times and food is always delicious. Wait was a little long to get seated but apparently had tech issues so it’s understandable. Usually there’s not a long wait but the food is waiting for you on the table when you sit down and you’ll enjoy a drink at the bar while you wait. Recommend!