Nite Cap Inn - PALMYRA

American, German, Fish
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Nite Cap Inn

Nite Cap Inn
4.3 / 5 (1162 reviews)

Menu

The restaurant from PALMYRA offers 45 different dishes and drinks on the menu at an average price of $11.7.

The Nite Cap Inn offers an authentic dining experience that perfectly captures Wisconsin's beloved fish fry tradition. With a charming atmosphere and attentive service, diners rave about the exceptional fish fry, especially the beer-battered varieties and delicious potato pancakes. While some may find the venue unassuming, it’s the quality of the food and the friendly vibe that keep patrons returning. The menu also includes delightful German dishes and desserts like key lime cheesecake, making it a well-rounded destination for all. For those seeking authentic local cuisine, the Nite Cap Inn is a must-visit gem that should not be missed.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Brett

Images

Nite Cap Inn Food Nite Cap Inn Outside Nite Cap Inn Outside Nite Cap Inn Menu Nite Cap Inn Menu Nite Cap Inn Menu Nite Cap Inn Menu Nite Cap Inn Menu

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 1162 reviews

Was Brian Spath at Nite Cap Inn a mag?
**Dining Experience** **Meal Type:** Dinner **Price Range:** $10–20 per person **Recommended Dishes:** Beer-Battered Fish, Potato Pancakes, Baked Cod, Deep-Fried Jumbo Shrimp If you're looking for a satisfying dinner without breaking the bank, this restaurant is a great choice. The menu features some standout dishes, including the delicious beer-battered fish and crispy potato pancakes. The baked cod is also a must-try, offering a flaky, tender texture that pairs perfectly with its seasonings. Don't miss out on the deep-fried jumbo shrimp—crispy on the outside and succulent on the inside, they're sure to impress seafood lovers. Overall, it's a wonderful place to enjoy a hearty meal.

What Deb Meisner dislikes about Nite Cap Inn:
The fish was frozen breaded processed. The fries were baked and hard, the baked fish was soggy and tasteless. Don’t wast your time. Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner View all feedback.

nick-cairns-dog676
16.11.2023

My buddy brought me to experience a classic 'sconni fish fry and this place didn 't disappoint. Glad I was with experienced friends as I would have had no idea I needed to know what to order as I walked in. Got to sit at the insanely classic bar and drink classic supper club drinks. Then once our table was ready, we moved over and had a top notch dinner. The fish was cooked to absolute perfection. Frys were as well. Had some blueberry cheesecake and that was amazing too. If you want the real deal, classic Friday fish fry experience... This is the place. Just remember be ready when you walk in... Chicken, cod, or walleye? Potato cakes, French fries, or slaw? Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Walleye Supper, Wiener Schnitzel

brian-spath
16.11.2023

**Dining Experience** **Meal Type:** Dinner **Price Range:** $10–20 per person **Recommended Dishes:** Beer-Battered Fish, Potato Pancakes, Baked Cod, Deep-Fried Jumbo Shrimp If you're looking for a satisfying dinner without breaking the bank, this restaurant is a great choice. The menu features some standout dishes, including the delicious beer-battered fish and crispy potato pancakes. The baked cod is also a must-try, offering a flaky, tender texture that pairs perfectly with its seasonings. Don't miss out on the deep-fried jumbo shrimp—crispy on the outside and succulent on the inside, they're sure to impress seafood lovers. Overall, it's a wonderful place to enjoy a hearty meal.

glenn-lazich
16.11.2023

Classic old-school supper club. Be ready to place your order as soon as you walk in. You can sit at the bar while you wait for your table and your meal. Service was good. Meal type: Dinner.

brett-crusan
20.08.2024

Been here a couple times and food is always delicious. Wait was a little long to get seated but apparently had tech issues so it’s understandable. Usually there’s not a long wait but the food is waiting for you on the table when you sit down and you’ll enjoy a drink at the bar while you wait. Recommend!

nick-cairns-bank42
20.08.2024

My buddy brought me to experience a classic 'sconni fish fry and this place didn 't disappoint. Glad I was with experienced friends as I would have had no idea I needed to know what to order as I walked in.Got to sit at the insanely classic bar and drink classic supper club drinks. Then once our table was ready, we moved over and had a top notch dinner. The fish was cooked to absolute perfection. Frys were as well. Had some blueberry cheesecake and that was amazing too.If you want the real deal, classic Friday fish fry experience... This is the place.Just remember be ready when you walk in... Chicken, cod, or walleye? Potato cakes, French fries, or slaw? ??

  • Hors D'oeuvres

    Cheese Spread Crackers
    Cheese Spread Crackers
    $5.7
  • Thursday & Saturday, American Cuisine

    Stuffed Shrimp With Pasta
    Stuffed Shrimp With Pasta
    $13.9
  • Starters

    Kasseler Ripchen (Smoked Pork Chops)
    Kasseler Ripchen (Smoked Pork Chops)
    $16.9
    Hungarian Paprika Goulash
    Hungarian Paprika Goulash
    $16.9
  • Wednesday & Friday

    Battered, Deep-Fried Cod
    Battered, Deep-Fried Cod
    $12.0
  • Old Family Favorites

    Beef Tenderloin Shrimp
    Beef Tenderloin Shrimp
    $19.9

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.