Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What User likes about Teddy's Bully:
We’re thrilled to have a fantastic new alternative to Canterbury’s in Oyster Bay. The food is delicious, the service is friendly, and the atmosphere is cozy. The crab cakes were amazing, and I usually don’t even like crab cakes! The fish tacos were spot on, and everything was delicious. It’s a lovely spot to unwind, enjoy a drink, and grab a bite in OYSTER BAY—don’t miss out on this place! View all feedback.
What User doesn't like about Teddy's Bully:
As a customer of the bar that previously occupied this location for 25 years, I arrived at Teddy’s with high hopes. My wife and I entered around 6 PM on a Friday, and the place was relatively quiet at that time. I approached the bar and waited for about five minutes while the bartender chatted with her friends at the far end, completely ignoring me. A simple acknowledgment like "I'll be right with you" would have suf... View all feedback.
I live in the neighborhood. The live music and atmosphere of the bar is great but the food is just God awful. I 've been there for dinner at least 5 times since they first opened and every time I 've told myself never again but I 'd eventually give it a try once more, hoping the food would improve over time. That was wishful thinking. Tonight we ordered appetizers to go because we had guests coming over for early cocktails on our deck. (Calamari, flatbreads, nachos the roasted corn). The food became the butt of jokes for our happy hour because it was so embarrassingly bad. Pictured here is their $18 nachos. This is how it came. Little plastic containers and stale chips like you 'd get at a sub par public snack bar. Look close at the cold, runny cheese ... And the flatbreads and calamari were like something you 'd get frozen from Costco. Just embarrassing and sad!
Visited around 5pm. Very mellow, casual crowd. Great food: fish tacos and fig/prosciutto flat bread are our favorites. Vegetables available upon request. Very nice staff. Family friendly place. I brought my 8 year old and everyone was very nice to her. They do have a kids menu and crayons/fun menu for them to draw on.
This place is so cool! To be in Teddy's area and enjoy Sagamore Hill this is the spot to check out
We’re thrilled to have a fantastic new alternative to Canterbury’s in Oyster Bay. The food is delicious, the service is friendly, and the atmosphere is cozy. The crab cakes were amazing, and I usually don’t even like crab cakes! The fish tacos were spot on, and everything was delicious. It’s a lovely spot to unwind, enjoy a drink, and grab a bite in Oyster Bay—don’t miss out on this place!
We had a wonderful experience at the restaurant, thanks to the friendly and attentive staff. Our server, Stephanie, was amazing, and the manager, Gina, made us feel very welcome. The food was extraordinary; we enjoyed a dozen super fresh oysters, BBQ chicken kebabs, and BBQ pulled pork. The cocktails were also outstanding—both the coconut margarita and the Alice were delicious!
Full Menu
Cocktail
Drinks
These Types Of Dishes Are Being Served
Main
More information
QR-code link to the menu
