Ossining Pizzeria - Feedback

Service: Takeout Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 2/5 Service: 1/5 Atmosphere: 1/5 Parking: There’s plenty of parking available, wit... read more Service: Takeout Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 2/5 Service: 1/5 Atmosphere: 1/5 Parking: There’s plenty of parking available, with free parking lot options.

Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza Parking space Plenty of parking P... read more Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza Parking space Plenty of parking Parking options Free parking lot

Walk into this so called “ landmark” ossining pizza and I couldn’t even explain the rudeness I received from the older gentleman in front . I ask them can we ha... read more Walk into this so called “ landmark” ossining pizza and I couldn’t even explain the rudeness I received from the older gentleman in front . I ask them can we have a table for 2 and proceeds to tell me that we aren’t serving anything besides pizza . So I proceeded to ask can we sit and have pizza inside and he tells me no only take out then just walks away. Totally understand people have bad days but this is the last straw walking into this place and the whole staff is rude! Definitely wouldn’t recommend this place! Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1

Standard pizzaria, but pies have an incredible crust- light and airy- served piping hot. Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Servi... read more Standard pizzaria, but pies have an incredible crust- light and airy- served piping hot. Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 3 Vegetarian offerings: Clearly labeled vegetarian dishes

Excellent pizza with fun rotating specialty flavors Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4 read more Excellent pizza with fun rotating specialty flavors Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4

Stopped in on a lark on our way home from nyc, wish I lived closer now, food was amazing, service was great. Will definitely stop by again if in the area. read more Stopped in on a lark on our way home from nyc, wish I lived closer now, food was amazing, service was great. Will definitely stop by again if in the area.

Found out later they hadn't opened for dine in yet. But they were very gracious and accomadated us to a fantastic dinner. Thanks to the owners father who took c... read more Found out later they hadn't opened for dine in yet. But they were very gracious and accomadated us to a fantastic dinner. Thanks to the owners father who took care of us and was a pleasure.

Excellent pizza went there for the first time last week. Tried a regular slice and a chicken slice. Both were very good and in particular, non greasy and no oil... read more Excellent pizza went there for the first time last week. Tried a regular slice and a chicken slice. Both were very good and in particular, non greasy and no oil dripping. Crust was very crunchy and tasty. Highly recommend this place.

You might be curious about why I rated this place 4 stars despite my disappointment. A few days ago, I ordered a delivery pizza—garlic and pepperoni—and it was... read more You might be curious about why I rated this place 4 stars despite my disappointment. A few days ago, I ordered a delivery pizza—garlic and pepperoni—and it was outstanding. This restaurant truly knows how to make pizza; if it weren't for my lackluster experience with the slices, they would have easily earned 5 stars and possibly claimed the title of my second-favorite pizza in town. I recommend stopping by for a quick lunch, but you might want to skip the slices and opt for a whole pizza instead. Or even better, do what I should have done and request your slice to be cooked well done.

The finest pizza in Ossining! It’s an outstanding New York slice that exceeds all expectations. Don’t miss out on the Ziti disc and the chicken parm disc—they'r... read more The finest pizza in Ossining! It’s an outstanding New York slice that exceeds all expectations. Don’t miss out on the Ziti disc and the chicken parm disc—they're both truly exceptional!

EXCELLENT PIZZA FOOD OSSINING PIZZA! WORTH THE DRIVE THEIR BUFFALO CHICKEN FINGER SLICE IS THE BEST SLICE EVER read more EXCELLENT PIZZA FOOD OSSINING PIZZA! WORTH THE DRIVE THEIR BUFFALO CHICKEN FINGER SLICE IS THE BEST SLICE EVER

My sons really love the chicken bacon pizza, and the tiramisu is truly exceptional! read more My sons really love the chicken bacon pizza, and the tiramisu is truly exceptional!

Why did I give this place four stars despite my disappointment? I ordered a delivery pizza with garlic and pepperoni, and I have to say, they really know how to... read more Why did I give this place four stars despite my disappointment? I ordered a delivery pizza with garlic and pepperoni, and I have to say, they really know how to make a great pizza. If it hadn't been for the issue with the slices, I would have rated it five stars—it's possibly the second best pizza I've had in the city so far. I think it's worth considering for a quick lunch, although their à la carte options look tempting enough that I might want to try them as well. If you decide to visit, I recommend ordering a whole pizza or, as I should have done, requesting your slice to be well done.

On my way home from NYC, I stopped at this restaurant and found myself wishing I lived nearby. The food was amazing, and the service was top-notch. I will defin... read more On my way home from NYC, I stopped at this restaurant and found myself wishing I lived nearby. The food was amazing, and the service was top-notch. I will definitely come back whenever I'm in the area.

Great choices of pizza and great restaurant read more Great choices of pizza and great restaurant

So, why did I give a 4-star rating despite my disappointment? A few days ago, I ordered a whole pizza with garlic and pepperoni for delivery, and it was fantast... read more So, why did I give a 4-star rating despite my disappointment? A few days ago, I ordered a whole pizza with garlic and pepperoni for delivery, and it was fantastic. This place truly excels at making great pizza; it would have easily scored 5 stars and could be the second-best pizza I've had in town if not for my experience with a slice. If you're thinking about stopping by for a quick lunch, I recommend avoiding the slice and opting for a whole pizza instead. Alternatively, take my suggestion and ask for your slice to be well-done!

I ordered three delicious wedges for dinner, and it was fantastic! Dining at this local pizzeria is always a wonderful experience. read more I ordered three delicious wedges for dinner, and it was fantastic! Dining at this local pizzeria is always a wonderful experience.

This is the best pizza in Ossining, offering a high-quality New York slice that exceeds any expectations. Make sure to try the ziti slice and the chicken parmes... read more This is the best pizza in Ossining, offering a high-quality New York slice that exceeds any expectations. Make sure to try the ziti slice and the chicken parmesan slice—they're essential choices!

The pizza that we had was amazing Great place read more The pizza that we had was amazing Great place

I visited this restaurant with my son and we had a wonderful experience. The staff were very friendly, and we ordered a couple of slices of pizza along with an... read more I visited this restaurant with my son and we had a wonderful experience. The staff were very friendly, and we ordered a couple of slices of pizza along with an empanada. The food was freshly prepared, and the place itself is small and cozy. We had a great time and will definitely be back!

Awful experience. The food quality was very disappointing—overly greasy and the plain slices tasted like nothing. The staff behind the counter also had terrible... read more Awful experience. The food quality was very disappointing—overly greasy and the plain slices tasted like nothing. The staff behind the counter also had terrible attitudes for reasons unknown to me. This place was fantastic before the pandemic (in 2020 and earlier). Do yourself a favor and go to Capri instead, where you'll enjoy excellent customer service and delicious pizza. I wouldn't recommend this restaurant to anyone.

The pizza is delicious with a thin, crispy crust. read more The pizza is delicious with a thin, crispy crust.