Casey's - Oshkosh

Pizza, Coffee, Cheese

Casey's

★ 3.6 / 5 (343 reviews)

This restaurant, frequently criticized for its pricing issues and questionable food quality, has drawn significant ire from patrons. Customers report inconsistency in portion sizes, with beverages not matching advertised quantities. Complaints extend to food safety, as some have experienced severe illness after dining, citing low-quality ingredients and poorly reheated items. Furthermore, customer service leaves much to be desired, with instances of rudeness among staff detracting from the overall experience. Despite a couple of positive anecdotes about cleanliness and a friendly employee, the overwhelming feedback suggests that significant improvements are necessary for this establishment to regain customer trust.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Aaron

Images

Contribute

Feedback

★ 3.6 / 5 from 343 reviews

Was Aaron Kleiser at Casey's a mag?
I regret not asking out the cute girl with amazing tattoos who works at the register, haha. Other than that, I have always had positive experiences at this restaurant. I helped with the construction of the place when it was built and it has always been clean. View all feedback.

What mitch snyder dislikes about Casey's:
Do you think I forgot that you kicked me out for not wearing a mask? And then you tried to sell me one! I hope your restaurant goes out of business because you will never get my business again. View all feedback.

Casandra

02.01.2024

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Cheese bread is the best around! Pizza is pretty damn good too!

mitch

02.01.2024

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Do you think I forgot that you kicked me out for not wearing a mask? And then you tried to sell me one! I hope your restaurant goes out of business because you will never get my business again.

Stefanie

02.01.2024

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Simple acknowledgement of a sole customer would be nice. Breaking employee conversation to welcome your only customer may bring revenue. It’s such a simple yet unpracticed concept.

Aaron

02.01.2024

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

I regret not asking out the cute girl with amazing tattoos who works at the register, haha. Other than that, I have always had positive experiences at this restaurant. I helped with the construction of the place when it was built and it has always been clean.

Brody

02.01.2024

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

The man with the large beard who works as the evening cashier is always a pleasure to interact with whenever I visit.

Feedback

Sweet Desserts

Brownie Bites
Bite‐sized chocolate brownies coated in a rich chocolate icing. This treat pairs perfectly + a slice of pizza.

$3.7
Add-Ons

Bleu Cheese
Get ready for this amazing sauce; made from artisan bleu cheese crumbles; for a tangy creamy sauce. Add it to your ready‐made salad; / pair + the Buffalo sauce for an ultimate dip combo. Dip your Casey’s boneless & traditional wings; / your favorit

$0.8
Crazy Good Wings.

Garlic Parmesan
Savory blend of real parmesan cheese & roasted garlic finished + crushed black pepper.

$0.8
Sauces

Honey Mustard
Tasty blend of Dijon mustard & a touch of honey; makes this sauce a delicious addition to any meal. Perfect pairing for the boneless & traditional wings; your favorite Casey’s pizza; / any of our on‐the‐go sandwiches. Add to your order now for same‐d

$0.8

Ranch
$0.8
Chicken

Buffalo Chicken
Another classic sauce; made + a blend of cayenne pepper & other spices. Try + the traditional & boneless wings; your favorite pizza; / add to your Crispy Casey’s Chicken Sandwich. Add to your order now for same‐day delivery; curbside pick‐up; o

$0.8