McCabes - Orillia

#28 - Cafés - Orillia, American, Canadian
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

McCabes

McCabes
2.3 / 5 (16 reviews)

Menu

Here you will find the menu of McCabes in Orillia. At the moment, there are 13 meals and drinks on the list.

McCabes, located at the Highwayman Inn in Orillia, received mixed reviews. While some guests were unimpressed by the limited menu, rundown appearance, and questionable cleanliness, others had a great experience with attentive service, delicious food, and reasonable prices. Bonny, in particular, stood out for her exceptional service during dinner and breakfast. The buffet was a hit for those looking for a wider selection. Overall, McCabes seems to offer a mixed bag of experiences, with some guests highly recommending it and others suggesting improvements are needed.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Muskoka

Images

McCabes Food McCabes Food McCabes Food McCabes Food

Feedback

★ 2.3 / 5 from 16 reviews

Was Anonym at McCabes a mag?
On our way home from cottage country we stopped in to McCabes for breakfast and found out there was a buffet (instead of their menu) which had everything I wanted and more (not as extensive as their Sunday brunch but still a nice selection). The waitress said we could order eggs any style if we didn't want the scrambled in the buffet. My husband didn't fancy the buffet so asked if they could do him some eggs benedict... View all feedback.

What Anonym dislikes about McCabes:
Went for breakfast, very limited menu, the roof was leaking the benches are all ripped and cracked and the place was not clean at all. Got coffee while trying to look at the menu and the cream has gone bad. That was the tipping point, no chance I'm risking eating in this place! View all feedback.

Went for breakfast, very limited menu, the roof was leaking the benches are all ripped and cracked and the place was not clean at all. Got coffee while trying to look at the menu and the cream has gone bad. That was the tipping point, no chance I'm risking eating in this place!

Got in late to the Highwayman and we wanted a bite to eat so we walked over to the restaurant attached. They advertise for their burgers in the hotel room, so I got one expecting it was homemade beef patty, but it was just a frozen patty, greasy, nothing special. The good thing was it was Open mic-entertainment was more enjoyable than the food.

On our way home from cottage country we stopped in to McCabes for breakfast and found out there was a buffet (instead of their menu) which had everything I wanted and more (not as extensive as their Sunday brunch but still a nice selection). The waitress said we could order eggs any style if we didn't want the scrambled in the buffet. My husband didn't fancy the buffet so asked if they could do him some eggs benedict and the waitress who was excellent and attentive said certainly and when he received them they were excellent, wish I'd ordered the same but the buffet was delicious too. Looking forward to going back real soon. Really good value, great food and excellent service.

muskoka-food-e
04.03.2024

My husband and I dined at this restaurant for breakfast last Wednesday. Apart from us, there was just one other table taken by two women and their group of...

beautiful-d-2
04.03.2024

This restaurant is situated in the Highwayman Inn Conference Centre in Orillia. I visited during the week, and the venue was nearly empty, with only a few local diners present.

Full Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.