Casey's - O'Neill

Pizza, Breakfast, Lunch

Casey's

Casey's
4.1 / 5 (213 reviews)

Menu

A complete overview of all 4 meals and beverages can be found here on the menu of Casey's from O'Neill.

Casey's in Oneill, NE presents a mixed but improving picture: pizzas and other offerings can be satisfying and the store is often clean with usable restrooms, yet inconsistent service and order errors persist. Customers note long waits, missing toppings, and occasional rude staff or managers, balanced by recent operational improvements and friendlier encounters. It remains a convenient highway stop for travelers and repeat visitors who value the menu but should double-check orders and expect delays during busy periods.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Robert

Images

Casey's Food Casey's Food Casey's Food Casey's Food Casey's Logo Casey's Food Casey's Menu Casey's Menu

Feedback

★ 4.1 / 5 from 213 reviews

Was Stephen Gillane at Casey's a mag?
Make sure to stop by! This is the final Casey’s if you're traveling west on US 20. It's definitely worth a visit if you're in the mood for pizza or other offerings from Casey’s. I highly recommend checking it out. The store was clean, and the bathroom was in good condition. The staff were friendly and attentive too. Overall, I had a great experience, just like always. View all feedback.

What Matthew dislikes about Casey's:
The manager at Casey's is really bad she not nice some people that come in and always mean and yelling at her worker she needs change her attitude or get fired Food: 5 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 3 View all feedback.

jackie-winsor
14.11.2023

Could you please invest in some new squeegees? It would really help customers clean their windshields.

stephen
14.11.2023

Make sure to stop by! This is the final Casey’s if you're traveling west on US 20. It's definitely worth a visit if you're in the mood for pizza or other offerings from Casey’s. I highly recommend checking it out. The store was clean, and the bathroom was in good condition. The staff were friendly and attentive too. Overall, I had a great experience, just like always.

weston-keyes
14.11.2023

I was informed that my pizza would take 45 minutes, but after that time passed, I've now been waiting an additional 30 minutes.

robert-ollendick-2
08.03.2025

Abrasive staff! Food: 2 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1

kimberly-wallinger
08.03.2025

The last 3 times we ordered pizza it was wrong. The ticket was right so I never opened it until I got home. Get charged for extra toppings but they don't get added. Very frustrating. Food: 1 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 4

Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.