Casey's - Olney

#24 - Pizza - Olney, Breakfast, Lunch
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Casey's

Casey's
3.8 / 5 (1175 reviews)

Description

At this Olney Casey’s, generous, affordable pizzas, a wide variety, and notable mobile app support make it a convenient gas‑station combo popular with regulars and students. Crispy bone‑in wings and friendly service are highlights, but experiences vary: pre‑made deli items limit customization, pizza preparation can be sloppy, and peak times bring long lines or cancelled orders. Occasional staff inattentiveness and inconsistent quality temper the overall value, making it a good quick‑stop option if you accept some unpredictability.

Last update: 21.03.2026 from: Mathew

Feedback

★ 3.8 / 5 from 1175 reviews
bigt7499
04.09.2024

I'm a regular at this place, and I stop by every day for a slice of pizza during lunch at the high school. Recently, I've been experiencing some harassment from others, but the manager has stepped in and has had enough. She’s even considering banning those individuals. That’s how you manage a business, and that’s what I call excellent customer service!

ethan-jennings-1
04.09.2024

The staff is extremely friendly, and the quality of the coffee is quite good. We could use more gas station employees like them!

donnie-keller-1
04.09.2024

Definitely one of the top three Casey's in the area! In my opinion, they have the best breakfast pizza around.

mathew-deain
04.09.2024

Grumpy workers sometimes. But that happens with customer care.... lol

ryan-buckley-restaur
04.09.2024

Rude cashiers, empty shelves, and a dirty store. Doesn't seem to be anyone in charge, and if there is, they should be embarrassed.

FAQ

You can also pay for your dishes with various credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.