Nutmeg's Cafe - Okeechobee

American, Cafe, Soup
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Nutmeg's Cafe

Nutmeg's Cafe
4.7 / 5 (1143 reviews)

Menu

A complete overview of all 21 meals and beverages can be found here on the menu of Nutmeg's Cafe from Okeechobee.

Nestled in the heart of Okeechobee, Nutmegs Café has quickly become a beloved dining destination known for its unique and delicious sandwiches. Guests rave about standout options like the Mouse Trap and Hog Trap Paninis, featuring a delightful cheese blend and savory meats. The café offers generous portions of fresh and healthy fare, making it a hit among vegetarians. Patrons also appreciate the friendly and attentive service in the charming, spacious dining area. While some side dishes may not impress, the tantalizing cupcakes and innovative sandwich combinations, such as the Peanut Butter Bacon, ensure a memorable culinary experience worth repeating.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Dakota

Images

Nutmeg's Cafe Food Nutmeg's Cafe Food

Feedback

★ 4.7 / 5 from 1143 reviews

Was Anonym at Nutmeg's Cafe a mag?
We ordered two half Panini sandwiches based on previous reviews, and they definitely lived up to the hype—they were delicious! My wife tried the Mouse Trap, which was packed with a cheese blend reminiscent of pimento cheese, while I opted for the Hog Trap, loaded with ham and salami. Both sandwiches were fantastic! The potato salad, made with a mustard base, was also quite tasty. View all feedback.

ansley-brakus
26.04.2023

Charming and down-to-earth café with a friendly, professional, and discreet service. The food was incredibly fresh and delicious. I ordered the tuna salad croissant, while my friend had the 15-bean soup, which he described as excellent.

jwuckert-firefighter
26.04.2023

If you haven't had the pleasure of eating at Nutmegs Çafe , you are missing out on a treasure of a place . This is my third visit to Okeechobee and my third visit to Nutmegs! My grandniece and I totally enjoyed our sandwiches (tuna melt and the famous bacon and peanut butter). We finished off our lunch with very tasty cupcakes (chocolate and red velvet). We will make Nutmegs Çafe a stop for their awesome food! Side note, very friendly and hardworking staff! Very neat and clean, bathroom included! Make it a point to stop in!o Nutmegs!

dakota-kovacek
26.04.2023

We ordered two half Panini sandwiches based on previous reviews, and they definitely lived up to the hype—they were delicious! My wife tried the Mouse Trap, which was packed with a cheese blend reminiscent of pimento cheese, while I opted for the Hog Trap, loaded with ham and salami. Both sandwiches were fantastic! The potato salad, made with a mustard base, was also quite tasty.

dakota-kovacek
26.04.2023

We always use Nutmegs when at Sebring. It’s rare that our crew of 40+ can all agree on food and we get rave reviews from everyone. Megan and her team are amazing to work with. Almost hate to give a 5 star review (because we worry you’ll be too busy! but truly deserves a 10 !! Thanks for making life easier and better for our team.

zarubova-sarka
26.04.2023

Place is SO adorable! Loved how big the dining area was, surprised to see a cute shopping booth in the back. All of our sandwiches were made fresh wait wasn’t long. The Caprese panini was amazing, especially with the vinaigrette! But didn’t love that meat was extra, when the price was already high. The Chicken Spinach Panini was perfect and would enjoy again. Sides were less impressive.. English Pea Salad very unique good for pickle lovers. Cupcakes are an O.K. treat to grab locally but didn’t love them. We would come by again to try more on the menu!

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.