Pizzaiola - Oceanside

#2 - Pizza - Oceanside, Italian, Vegetarian Friendly

Pizzaiola

Pizzaiola
3.8 / 5 (1272 reviews)

Description

Pizzaiola in Oceanside, NY, is a highly regarded Italian restaurant, proudly holding an average rating of 4.1 stars. Open daily from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, this popular dining spot invites you to indulge in authentic Italian cuisine. To secure your table, feel free to reserve by calling (516) 594-3939. Prefer to enjoy your meal at home? Pizzaiola offers convenient delivery through Uber Eats and DoorDash. Additionally, you'll find a delightful wine selection to complement your dining experience. If you're exploring similar menus, don’t miss out on Jessy's Pastries and Chipotle Mexican Grill. Have you dined with us before? We’d love to hear your feedback, so leave a review!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Bonni

Feedback

★ 3.8 / 5 from 1272 reviews
jcayman
06.04.2025

We had a Margherita slice, Grandma slice, and a regular slice. They were all good, but I preferred the Margherita. We also had a house salad, which was decent and fresh. And we split ravioli in a fra diavlo sauce, which was quite tasty. Everything was freshand delicious. The service and staff were great. The place was clean and welcoming!

babbal-bhandari
06.04.2025

Very overpriced for a regular slice and one order of garlic knots was over $8 and like other customers the short bald gentleman really does seem to hate his job he does not know how to greet customers instead he stares at them waiting for them to speak hedid not heat my order I specially told him to go in the beginning and yet he still seemed confused if it was dine in or to goalso anytime you say thank you to him you never hear a response he really seems like he hates his job and people! the food was he overpriced, cold and very bland as for the gentleman behind the counter he did seem like a nice guy probably experiencingburnout of some sorts I hope management sees to it that his needs are met or that he is offered a different role in theestablishment :

shariff-ahmed
06.04.2025

I ordered plain cheese pizza As I'm eating I'm noticing pepperoni pepperoni I don't eat pepperoni I didn't ask for pepperoni , I call them she has me on hold She didn't know how to solve the problem so I just hanged up and made a review

bonni-weiss-1
06.04.2025

It pains me to have to leave this review because we've been a customer of Pizzaola for 20 years but there is something seriously wrong with the staff behind the counter. Im specifically talking about the short bald guy. On more ocassions than one, he hasbeen horribly rude to my family and we have been nothing but kind, loyal customers. He has such an attitude and everytime we goin there he takes it out on us. After our third bad interaction we had which included ignoring us when it was our turn to bewaited on and not responding with even so much as a grunt when we said thank you for the pizza, we decided we have had enough.Who treats their customers this way? This disgusting behavior seems specifically directed at certain customers too. We overheardthe same staff member being nice to others which made us feel even worse. Despite the pizza being really good, on principle weprobably won't eat here again. We've also told multiple people Pizzaolas staff is disrespectful and we suspect possibly racist.Such a shame but a business should honestly care more about disgruntled employees and being nice to their customers. Wonderingif anyone else had similar interactions? Please like this review if you have. I'm curious.

christine-weiss-gras
06.04.2025

Ate at Pizzaiola last Monday. The food was delicious but when I went to get bread out of the bread basket, I was shocked to see mold on it. The waitress insisted it was charred. Charred is black and this was green. Will not be going back. Just glad Ihad already eaten my dinner bc when I saw that, I lost the rest of my appetite!

Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.