Spilt Milk - Oak Park

The new space is absolutely amazing, very friendly and inviting, and an expanded selection of not only delicious pastries but great pantry items. They also sell wine. What would be better than picking up a bottle of wine and some delicious quiche, with a incredible cinnamon roll to finish? Well worth the stop to check out the new place!

Spilt Milk continues to impress me. I don’t live in Oak Park, but make a point to stop in anytime I’m in the area for a brown butter cookie or a savory biscuit. The staff are always so friendly and welcoming. They also have an amazing selection of dry goods, great stuff to grab if you’re have a party or need a unique gift (including an eclectic wine selection! You can tell the team here truly cares about their business, their product, and their customers. Happy to continue to support this small business.

The store is nicely layed out and the pies are incredible. I thought I had a key lime pie before. After eating this one, all will forever pale in comparison.

Oak Park's greatest bakery and pastry shop. While their reputation is built on their pies, scones, cookies, and other baked goods, don't overlook their lunch items. They are just as incredible as the rest of the menu.

I popped in by chance a couple of days ago while running errands. I love this place. I haven't seen or had chess pie in ages, it's especially rare to see in the Midwest. I had a slice and the next day I was back to buy a whole pie for a work party. There was a line from one end of the store to the door but I was lucky enough to snag one. And they were suprisingly fast with service, something tells me these lines happen often. This was at 8:30am on a Saturday. The chess pie was a huge hit! My coworkers inhaled it, many of which had never heard of chess pie. I swear it's just crack in carb form they make at this bakery and I am here for it. After a long night at work I went back to try a hand pie and opted for the chicken mole. My god it was so unexpectedly good. So good I had to write a review while eating it and walking back to my apartment. I usually pop into the local bakeries after my night shifts for breakfast, hands down this place is now the top of my list. The pastry and pies may fool you into thinking it's down home baking, which it is, but after you take your first bite you realize it's professionally made comfort food. Which I feel a lot of places attempt but few can pull off as we as as Spilt Milk does. 11/10 would recommend.