Mamma Mias Pizzeria - Nutley

If I could give this place a negative star I would. I really have given place plenty of shots over the years but I’ve had nothing but consistent bad experiences. The last straw was I ordered a sandwich and went to pick it up within the window of time given, when I go there it wasn’t ready which is fine. After being told it would be just a few minutes and whether I wanted to pay at that point so I paid and waited. After waiting about ten minutes I asked about my order and the guy got an attitude and it turned into an argument so I asked to just get my money back and he refused and threatened to call the cops!! I left since my kid was waiting in the car for the past 15 minutes while I was waiting for one sandwich! Never again stay far away the food isn’t even good, it was just convenient!!

Restaurant was superior to any other I've ever been to. My dining experience at this fine establishment was like none I have ever experienced. Highly recommended

Food is mediocre. Inside looks dirty. They mess up the order every time I try to eat there. I even saw the owner or one of the cooks chewing tobacco while I was waiting for food....

Great pizza and Italian food...reasonable prices and no charge for delivery. Delivery staff are fast, courteous and careful! My favorite dish is the #4 Specialty Pasta with a side order of sauteed broccoli and a large house salad. Favorite pizza: the Cabrina's Special!

I visited this restaurant on 05/20/2022 and, as another reviewer mentioned, I found the older man at the counter to be very rude. He acted like he was the owner, but I doubt that he actually is. His demeanor was unkind and unwelcoming, making me feel like I wasn't even wanted there. One part of my order was 6 very small fried baby shrimp that cost me $11, which is possibly the highest price I've ever paid for this dish in the area. This left me feeling deceived. I also ordered an Italian sub with extra provolone, but only received one additional slice of cheese. I asked for mayo, but when I got to my car, I found no mayo or dressing on the sandwich. Instead, they had included two small packets of mayo and a cup of Italian dressing for salad in the bag. Isn't it a basic expectation for a sandwich to be prepared with the requested condiments? It was disappointing that my order was not fulfilled properly. To top it off, I paid $25.84 for an 8-inch Italian sandwich with barely any meat, 6 small fried shrimp, and a soda - a price that seemed excessive for the subpar service and food quality. I wouldn't recommend this place and I certainly won't be returning. Additionally, the kitchen's rear door was left wide open, providing easy access for bugs, rodents, and pests. After receiving the response from the eatery, I can confirm that the shrimp were not the jumbo ones they claimed. I will visit again and take a photo of the suspected jumbo shrimp to prove they were actually tiny. I have never experienced a situation where my condiments were placed on the side after being promised they would be on the sandwich. If the kitchen needs ventilation, they should invest in central air instead of leaving the back door open. Stop cutting corners.