Reviews
What Realtoyhunter doesn't like about Good Guys Pizza:
Went to Wurlizer Pizza/Jamie's Ice Cream today and was surprised to find out that their prices have sky rocketed. I ordered a small vegan polar blast and learned that not only did the price go up but the size is smaller. So I received less for more money. What a rip off. Won't go back. View all feedback. What Nikolai Vainola likes about Good Guys Pizza:
You should try the chicken finger sub it's not dry and not skimped on the chicken or lettuce like some pizza or sub shops like Wegmans they put less on but charge a lot. The pizza is great here too View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
The New York Style is my grandsons favorite. I like the thin crust myself.
Definitely the BEST pizza not only in North Tonawanda but I’d say the whole Buffalo area! Fresh ingredients, delicious sauce, crust is soft where it should be a...
read moreThe best pizza in WNY. Jay, Mike, and Mark are amazing owners. Only place to go for Pizza.
Good guys make me think of pizza junksion of decades ago. Had there beef on weck pizza. My god it was just like the real thing, but even better!
THIS is the place! This is definitely what any pizza lover is looking for. Best in the area!
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThe reviews for Wurlizer Pizza/Jamie's Ice Cream are mixed, with some customers expressing disappointment in their recent experiences while others highly praise the food and customer service. One customer complained about overpriced and smaller portions, while another raved about the chicken finger sub and pizza quality. Despite a few mishaps with orders and delivery, the majority of reviewers seem to appreciate the delicious food and excellent customer service provided by the restaurant.
No better pizza out there. Every element of her pizza is perfect! From speciality to standard cheese pepperoni is an example of cake perfection. The NY Style Pi...
read moreThis pizza is absolutely THICC, sometimes referred to a literal cake. They speak of a 1⁄2 inch thick layer of cheese with a perfect amount of sauce. Covered wit...
read moreTwo reasons for my 5-star rating: 1. The food is great, one of the best chicken finger subs in all Buffalo, thiccc pizza and amazing steakries. 2. The reason I...
read moreThe pizza is amazing. Full blows and simply brilliant! For the first time, she tried her chicken finger sub. Oh, yeah!
It's been a little while since ordering from Good Guys. It is still the best pizza you can get anywhere!!!! The only reason I gave it 4 stars instead of five is...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreI want to recommend a trusted and legit trader. I use to make little profits on trading options account but when I came in contact with Miss Linda james, I made...
read moreExtremely vegan friendly! Extensive vegan menu is posted right at the register, and wow, the stuffed banana pepper pizza was incredible! ?
Just ordered fingers (10) they are horrible .they are overcooked and u cant even bite into them the ends are hard...horrible..and I spent 21.00 ugh..never again
We order relatively frequently from Wurlitzer and the food is great! We did have an issue today with no bacon on my turkey club sub. We ordered through Slice an...
read moreLet me tell you what a joke this place is. We try to support local business when we can. But they have not gotten my order right in weeks. And tonight was the l...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreSmall cheese pep 10/10 Absolutely love how thick the cheese is. I like that they use regular pepperoni instead of your typical Buffalo cup and char. The...
Love this place ! Best pizza and wings! The staff is amazing! So friendly and helpful. They are all very hard workers. Especially on those hot summer...
A 1/2 tray is 12 slices. 12 slices were 6.5 lbs with the box. Half pound pizza slices. Seriously. I'm Sicilian, so I'm all about the crust. This one has...
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more