Notorious P.i.e. - Norman

#8 - Order Mexican Norman, #13 - Order Vegetarian Norman, Pizza
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Notorious P.i.e.

Notorious P.i.e.
4.3 / 5 (2338 reviews)

Description

Nestled in a charming downtown locale, this restaurant offers a delightful atmosphere, with friendly staff and a nostalgic vibe. Diners rave about the expansive menu, especially the pizzas, which some describe as the best they've ever had, featuring high-quality ingredients and generous portions perfect for sharing. Happy hour draws crowds with its enticing prices. However, not all experiences have been positive; inconsistencies in food quality and service have left some patrons frustrated. While the hummus and specific pizza varieties earn praise, a few diners report disappointing encounters with burnt offerings. Ultimately, the restaurant's potential shines brightly amidst the critiques.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Jacque

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 2338 reviews
nequel-b
01.12.2023

I visited this restaurant for the first time today. It's a charming spot located on Main Street. You have the option to park on the street or in the back parking lot. The atmosphere of the restaurant is laid-back with an old-school charm. The music was fantastic, and our server did an excellent job with our large group. The restaurant was prepared for our visit, and our appetizers came out promptly. The food was absolutely delicious.

berenice-w
01.12.2023

The Pizzas at this restaurant are amazing. The fried cheese NY pizza is one of the most delicious pizzas I've ever tried in Oklahoma. The portions are large, perfect for when you're really hungry. Plus, they reheat well so you can easily take leftovers home without worry. Highly recommend!

hailey-g-1
01.12.2023

The food was excellent! The bartender was very helpful and friendly. I will definitely be returning.

jacque-s-2
01.12.2023

Another great recommendation! Believe me, this pizza.... Oh my goodness, mind blown! This place is located downtown Norman, very cute area. I took my first bite and was in heaven! We had the NY style with pepperoni and green peppers. The staff was very kind and the atmosphere is fun but also laid back. Looks like a great place for the college kids, but parent-friendly too! We were only able to eat half of it, luckily we met a group of polite young men who took the rest home. (I hate wasting amazing food)

ryan-rafferty
01.12.2023

We came during happy hour between 3-6 and the prices are great. We had appetizers, a couple of slices, a mixed drink, and sodas for around $20 and it was all delicious. The staff was very nice and the restaurant was clean.

Menu

  • Greens

    Banana Pepper Caesar
    Banana Pepper Caesar

    Romaine & spinach; croutons; Parmesan; & fried pepperoni.

    $8.7
  • Sandwiches

    The Roasted Vegan Sandwich
    The Roasted Vegan Sandwich

    Cold Sub Vegan.Roasted carrot hummus; cucumber; roasted onion; banana peppers; roasted tomato; kalamata olives; spinach; roasted red peppers; garlic & basil infused olive oil.Served + chips.

    $12.5
    Who You Calling Turkey
    Who You Calling Turkey

    Cold Sub Roasted turkey; honey mustard; provolone; romaine; spinach; red onion; cherry tomatoes.

    $11.0
  • Munchies

    Best Boneless Wings
    Best Boneless Wings

    Choice of sauce: traditional buffalo; Jamaican jerk; / sweet & spicy ginger garlic. Served + carrots & bleu cheese dressing.

    $13.7
    Notorious Bruschetta
    Notorious Bruschetta

    Vegetarian. Crostinis topped + house ricotta cream; roasted tomato; fresh basil; & balsamic glaze drizzle.

    $7.5
  • Single Slice

    Fried Cheese Slice
    Fried Cheese Slice
    $6.0

FAQ

A little farther away is Greyhound-Norman, where you can also access the municipal transportation.

You can also enjoy gluten-free meals at the restaurant.

You can watch major sporting events on a screen / TV right in the restaurant.

The restaurant is accessible and can therefore also be used with a wheelchair or physiological limitations.

You can also pay for your menus with various credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.